Sálvio Spínola Fagundes Filho matches


© 
 
Date
2008-03-12
Match
Universidad Católica-River Plate
 
-
Result
1 - 2
Referee decisions
Yellow
2 - 4
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Our marks
6.3
6.6
Your marks
6
5.8
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmarès Matches by tournament
6
Control: Too many protests
7
Calls: Ok
7
Neutrality: Ok
5
Style: Weak
6.3
General assessment
 
Sálvio Spínola Fagundes Filho matches
'11-11-15 Colombia - Argentina (1 - 2)'11-08-24 Atletico Paranaense - Flamengo (0 - 1)'11-07-24 Uruguay - Paraguay (3 - 0)'11-07-12 Chile - Peru (1 - 0)'11-07-06 Argentina - Colombia (0 - 0)'11-05-18 Libertad - Vélez Sarsfield (2 - 4)'11-04-27 Estudiantes - Cerro Porteno (0 - 0)'11-04-19 Libertad - San Luis FC (2 - 0)'11-03-24 Vélez Sarsfield - Union Espanola (2 - 1)'11-02-24 Independiente - Peñarol (3 - 0)'10-09-29 Banfield - Deportes Tolima (2 - 0)'10-04-29 Once Caldas - Libertad (0 - 0)'10-03-31 Paraguay - South Africa (1 - 1)'10-03-23 Libertad - Universitario (1 - 1)'10-02-11 Estudiantes - Juan Aurich (5 - 1)'09-10-10 Ecuador - Uruguay (1 - 2)'09-10-01 Union Espanola - Vélez Sarsfield (2 - 2)'09-09-09 Paraguay - Argentina (1 - 0)'09-06-10 Venezuela - Uruguay (2 - 2)'09-05-21 Boca Juniors - Defensor Sporting (0 - 1)'09-04-07 River Plate - Nacional (UR) (0 - 0)'09-02-19 Universitario - San Lorenzo (1 - 0)'09-02-08 Venezuela u20 - Uruguay u20 (3 - 1)'09-02-02 Uruguay u20 - Colombia u20 (2 - 1)'09-01-27 Argentina u20 - Ecuador u20 (2 - 2)'09-01-23 Ecuador u20 - Colombia u20 (0 - 0)'08-10-15 Paraguay - Peru (1 - 0)'08-08-13 Internacional - Gremio (1 - 1)'08-03-20 Deportivo Cuenca - Lanús (1 - 1)• '08-03-12 Universidad Católica - River Plate (1 - 2)'08-02-20 Arsenal de Sarandí - Libertad (1 - 0)'07-11-20 Venezuela - Bolivia (5 - 3)'07-10-25 Defensor Sporting - River Plate (2 - 2)'07-09-05 Spain u17 - Ghana u17 (2 - 1)'07-09-02 England u17 - Germany u17 (1 - 4)'07-08-29 Spain u17 - Korea DPR u17 (3 - 0)'07-08-25 Belgium u17 - USA u17 (0 - 2)'07-08-20 Trinidad and Tobago u17 - Ghana u17 (1 - 4)'07-08-18 Costa Rica u17 - Togo u17 (1 - 1)'07-05-03 Nacional (UR) - Necaxa (3 - 2)'07-04-19 Gimnasia La Plata - Defensor Sporting (3 - 0)'07-03-16 Ecuador u17 - Colombia u17 (1 - 2)'07-03-13 Argentina u17 - Uruguay u17 (2 - 1)'07-03-07 Argentina u17 - Colombia u17 (0 - 0)'07-02-28 Vélez Sarsfield - Nacional (UR) (1 - 1)'07-02-01 Tacuary - LDU Quito (1 - 1)'06-09-06 Paraná - Atletico Paranaense (1 - 3)'06-05-02 Atlético Nacional - LDU Quito (0 - 1)'06-02-23 Rosario Central - Cerro Porteno (0 - 2)'06-02-02 Oriente Petrolero - River Plate (0 - 2)'05-11-23 Vélez Sarsfield - Pumas UNAM (0 - 0)'05-10-31 Bolivia u15 - Argentina u15 (1 - 3)'05-10-27 Peru u15 - Venezuela u15 (0 - 2)'05-09-01 Cruzeiro - Juventude-RS (0 - 1)'05-05-25 Sao Paulo - Palmeiras (2 - 0)'05-05-18 Palmeiras - Sao Paulo (0 - 1)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)
CONMEBOL COPA LIBERTADORES 2008 group stage:
Universidad Católica - River Plate, 1 - 2. San Carlos de Apoquindo, Santiago, Chile, 2008-03-12

Apparently, Fagundes started the match with the idea of booking nobody. What is more, during the first part of the game - let´s say 10 minutes - he didn´t even whistle. He tried to finish the 1st half without showing any card, but he couldn´t: Ponzio saw a yellow at 44´. And the game ended with 6 cards shown by the referee.

European or SouthAmerican?
Some people say that there´s an European style of refereeing, and another South American style, because we don´t see exactly the same kind of football here and there. In S.A., referees tend to be more severe in order to protect skilful players and players tend to break the rules more frequently. Fagundes likes to referee with an "European" style, but this can turn out to be a bit permissive. And it certainly was during the 1st half of this match.

Change
At 52´, Fagundes showed the second yellow of that 2nd half. No cards during first 44 minutes (1st half), 2 cards during first 7 minutes (2nd half). Fagundes changed during the rest and became more severe, but this wasn´t good at all, because, how does he explain that the same action could deserve nothing in the 1st half but a yellow in the 2nd? Fagundes calls weren´t bad, but we wasn´t coherent. His booking was not bad, but he should have started from the beginning.

Penalty?
There were some doubtful actions inside both areas, and Catolica players demanded a penalty when the 1st half was about to end. The action wasn´t clear but it could have been a penalty. However, TV didn´t repeat it properly.

From our reporter: Sheriff