WorldReferee.com - Pedro Proença matches

1) report by Luigi

8

Control: He controlled the game by the line he drew in the France/Sweden game

7

Calls: Mostly good. The crew has something to discuss in the post game meeting. AR called a much tighter game.

8

Neutrality:

8

Style: While I am not a Proenca fan, in this game I liked his style.

I expected a Italy/Ireland style game and instead we say a friendly. Was it because the players decided to play nice, or is it that they knew what Proenca would do if they acted stupid. As a result we all watched a rather nice game.

9

Control:

8

Calls:

10

Neutrality:

9

Style:

9

Control:

8

Calls:

9

Neutrality:

9

Style:

7

Control:

6

Calls:

6

Neutrality:

7

Style:

8

Control: easy game

8

Calls: some minors but no major

8

Neutrality: okay

7

Style: gentleman

above average as other matches at the tournament

10

Control:

9

Calls:

10

Neutrality:

10

Style:

best performance in the EURO.

8

Control:

8

Calls:

8

Neutrality:

8

Style:

Very good call by Miranda.

9

Control:

8

Calls:

8

Neutrality:

8

Style:

8

Control: He ignored minor fouls, but on the right moment he pulled the first yellow and as a consequence he maintained control.

7

Calls: A few very tight offside calls, but all right. Most calls were right, but there were some minor errors. First yellow was right, second yellow was wrong.

7

Neutrality: I would say that the shirt pulling in the penalty area (De Rossi vs Terry) could have resulted in a penalty for England. Proenca choose to punish a minor (or invisible?) foul from Terry instead.

7

Style: Good contact with the players. Let the match flow as much as possible.

Overall good performance. Let the game flow, but on the right moment pulled his first yellow. As a consequence he maintained control. Second yellow was wrong. The AR's were very good concerning the offside calls. They were indeed more strict in foul detection as Proenca was, which was a bad thing.

7

Control: Great Match flow, Italy almost playing without physical contact for almost over an hour and not much to control.

7

Calls: The assessment is right that there were different measures on the sidelines and in the centre of the field.

7

Neutrality: Italy got away with more things, but to be fair they also tried more and were a much more active team.

7

Style: Like all his other colleagues, he ignored things that could have got him into trouble (shirt-pulling or pushes in the box).

Pedro Proenca was good, but he chose to turn a blind eye to difficult things (e.g. inside the box). The cards were okayish, and I was surprised that England were really waiting for the penalties given their record in this discipline. Italy deserved to win because England had done an unbritish thing in a way: to give up for most of extra time that you can win it.

6

Control: He should thank the players, because they helped him a lot. If they weren't played like this, Proenca would be in a big trouble.

6

Calls: Not good card policy

4

Neutrality: Pro Italy for the whole game. 50-50 challenges always went to Italy"s way.

4

Style: Bad placement and alwas smiling. Not a good refereeing style..

8

Control:

6

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

8

Style:

the first yellow card was soft the second inesistant

7

Control:

7

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

8

Style:

8

Control:

7

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

6

Style:

indeed there was a difference in judgment between his and his ARs'

8

Control:

6

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

7

Style:

8

Control:

6

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

7

Style:

Proenca was too lenient, but his assistants were too strict: everytime they waved their flags for something Pedro would have let go, but couldnt then. He and his team should evaluate this

7

Control: Not much to control

6

Calls: 2nd yellow card terribly wrong

7

Neutrality: A bit pro-italy.

7

Style: Bad placement, good contact with the players. Too lenient.

Stop being in the way, Pedro! He was even too lenient for my taste. All the player knew each other and the mood on the pitch was friendly. Except all the tugging in the shirts, which he left unnoticed.

8

Control: good, but the player played very fairly

7

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

7

Style:

9

Control:

7

Calls:

9

Neutrality:

9

Style:

8

Control:

5

Calls:

7

Neutrality:

6

Style:

10

Control:

10

Calls:

10

Neutrality:

8

Style:

'13-02-14 Tottenham Hotspur - Lyon (2 - 1)'13-02-06 England - Brazil (2 - 1)'12-11-21 Ajax - Dortmund (1 - 4)'12-11-14 Netherlands - Germany (0 - 0)'12-10-24 Malaga - AC Milan (1 - 0)'12-10-16 Germany - Sweden (4 - 4)'12-09-19 Chelsea F.C. - Juventus (2 - 2)'12-09-11 Hungary - Netherlands (1 - 4)'12-08-21 Borussia Mönchengladbach - Dynamo Kyiv (1 - 3)'12-07-01 Spain - Italy (4 - 0)• '12-06-24 England - Italy (0 - 0)'12-06-19 Sweden - France (2 - 0)'12-06-14 Spain - Ireland (4 - 0)'12-05-29 Angola - Macedonia (0 - 0)'12-05-19 Bayern Munich - Chelsea F.C. (1 - 1)'12-03-29 Schalke 04 - Athletic Bilbao (2 - 4)'12-03-13 Internazionale - Marseille (2 - 1)'12-02-23 Anderlecht - AZ (0 - 1)'11-12-07 Lille OSC - Trabzonspor (0 - 0)'11-11-15 Croatia - Turkey (0 - 0)'11-11-02 Villarreal - Manchester City (0 - 3)'11-10-07 Serbia - Italy (1 - 1)'11-09-13 Olympiakos - Marseille (0 - 1)'11-09-02 Ireland - Slovakia (0 - 0)'11-08-17 Dinamo Zagreb - Malmö (4 - 1)'11-05-04 Manchester United - Schalke 04 (4 - 1)'11-03-15 Bayern Munich - Internazionale (2 - 3)'11-02-17 Besiktas - Dynamo Kyiv (1 - 4)'10-12-07 Manchester United - Valencia (1 - 1)'10-10-19 Real Madrid - AC Milan (2 - 0)'10-10-09 France - Romania (2 - 0)'10-09-14 Twente - Internazionale (2 - 2)'10-08-18 Salzburg - Hapoel Tel Aviv (2 - 3)'10-06-04 France - China (0 - 1)'10-04-08 Standard - Hamburger SV (1 - 3)'10-03-11 Rubin Kazan - Wolfsburg (1 - 1)'09-12-08 Zurich - AC Milan (1 - 1)'09-11-03 Bayern Munich - Bordeaux (0 - 2)'09-10-20 Olympiakos - Standard (2 - 1)'09-10-14 France - Austria (3 - 1)'09-09-16 Liverpool - Debrecen (1 - 0)'09-08-20 Fulham - Amkar Perm (3 - 1)'09-08-04 Panathinaikos - Sparta Prague (3 - 0)'09-06-26 Italy u21 - Germany u21 (0 - 1)'09-06-23 Serbia u21 - Sweden u21 (1 - 3)'09-06-16 Italy u21 - Serbia u21 (0 - 0)'09-03-28 Slovenia - Czech Republic (0 - 0)'09-03-19 Galatasaray - Hamburger SV (2 - 3)'08-12-18 Tottenham Hotspur - Spartak Moskva (2 - 2)'08-10-21 Zenit - BATE (1 - 1)'08-10-15 Italy - Montenegro (2 - 1)'08-10-02 Schalke 04 - APOEL (1 - 1)'08-08-27 Kaunas - AaB (0 - 2)'08-05-31 France - Paraguay (0 - 0)'08-02-13 Marseille - Spartak Moskva (3 - 0)'07-11-29 Tottenham Hotspur - AaB (3 - 2)'07-11-08 Austria Wien - Bordeaux (1 - 2)'07-09-19 PSV - CSKA Moskva (2 - 1)'07-09-08 Latvia - Northern Ireland (1 - 0)'07-08-15 Tampere - Rosenborg (0 - 3)'07-03-28 Malta - Greece (0 - 1)'07-02-14 Hapoel Tel Aviv - Glasgow Rangers (2 - 1)'06-11-30 Eintracht Frankfurt - Newcastle United (0 - 0)'06-10-06 Czech Republic u21 - Bosnia-Herzegovina u21 (2 - 1)'06-09-28 Randers - Fenerbahce SK (0 - 3)'06-07-26 Mlada Boleslav - Vålerenga (3 - 1)'05-10-20 CSKA Sofia - Hamburger SV (0 - 1)'05-09-15 AS Roma - Aris Thessaloniki (5 - 1)'05-08-03 Thun - Dynamo Kyiv (1 - 0)'05-02-24 Lille OSC - Basel (2 - 0)'04-12-01 Besiktas - Standard (1 - 1)'04-09-30 AEK - Gorica (1 - 0)'04-09-08 Kazakhstan - Ukraine (1 - 2)'04-07-24 Turkey u19 - Spain u19 (0 - 1)'04-07-15 Germany u19 - Poland u19 (3 - 1)'04-07-13 Switzerland u19 - Italy u19 (1 - 1)'03-09-05 Italy u21 - Wales u21 (8 - 1)'03-06-22 Zalgiris - Örgryte IS (1 - 1)

All matches