WorldReferee.com - Jose Hernando Buitrago matches

Date

2009-03-05

Match

Univ. San Martin

River Plate

Result

2 - 1

Yellow

4 - 4

Red

0 - 0

Penalty

1 - 0

this match

overall

Our marks

5.3

6.3

Your marks

5.8

5.9

Matches Bio Did you know? Palmarès Matches by tournament

Reporter's marks

Control: There were some skirmishes

Calls: Weak

Neutrality:

Style:

Assistants didn´t help, they wrongly flagged two or three times.

Other reports for this match (1)

1) report by carlos stroessner

Control:

Calls:

Neutrality:

Style:

Jose Hernando Buitrago matches

'13-05-23 Tijuana - Atlético Mineiro (2 - 2)'13-04-11 Olimpia Asuncion - Newell's Old Boys (4 - 1)'13-04-02 Emelec - Peñarol (2 - 0)'13-03-06 Libertad - Sporting Cristal (2 - 2)'13-02-13 Caracas FC - Fluminense (0 - 1)'13-02-03 Uruguay u20 - Ecuador u20 (1 - 0)'13-01-27 Paraguay u20 - Ecuador u20 (1 - 0)'13-01-14 Uruguay u20 - Ecuador u20 (2 - 2)'13-01-10 Brazil u20 - Ecuador u20 (1 - 1)'12-11-01 Cerro Porteno - Tigres (1 - 0)'12-09-25 Independiente - Liverpool (ur) (2 - 1)'12-08-29 Mineros de Guayana - Cerro Porteno (2 - 2)'12-08-01 Deportivo Quito - Leon de Huanuco (1 - 0)'12-06-09 Venezuela - Chile (0 - 2)'12-05-17 Boca Juniors - Fluminense (1 - 0)'12-05-02 Emelec - Corinthians (0 - 0)'12-03-15 Flamengo - Olimpia Asuncion (3 - 3)'12-03-07 Deportivo Quito - Vélez Sarsfield (3 - 0)'12-02-14 Zamora - Boca Juniors (0 - 0)'12-02-08 Vasco da Gama - Nacional (UR) (1 - 2)'11-11-29 Vélez Sarsfield - LDU Quito (0 - 1)'11-11-11 Paraguay - Ecuador (2 - 1)'11-10-12 Independiente - LDU Quito (1 - 0)'11-09-20 Emelec - Olimpia Asuncion (1 - 2)'11-09-14 Universitario - Deportivo Anzoátegui (2 - 0)'11-09-02 Ecuador - Jamaica (5 - 2)'11-08-06 Saudi Arabia u20 - Nigeria u20 (0 - 2)'11-04-14 Caracas FC - Vélez Sarsfield (0 - 3)'11-02-15 San Luis FC - Libertad (1 - 2)'11-02-01 Jaguaras Chiapas - Alianza Lima (2 - 0)'10-09-22 Sport Huancayo - Defensor Sporting (2 - 0)'10-05-29 Venezuela - Canada (1 - 1)'10-03-11 Deportivo Quito - Internacional (1 - 1)'10-03-06 Venezuela - Korea DPR (2 - 1)'10-03-03 Venezuela - Panama (1 - 2)'10-01-26 Deportivo Tachira - Libertad (1 - 0)'09-08-11 LDU Quito - Libertad (1 - 0)'09-04-23 Deportivo Cuenca - Boca Juniors (1 - 0)• '09-03-05 Univ. San Martin - River Plate (2 - 1)'09-01-27 El Nacional - Club Nacional (0 - 5)'08-10-22 Palmeiras - Argentinos Juniors (0 - 1)'08-10-11 Bolivia - Peru (3 - 0)'08-08-14 América de Cali - Deportivo Cali (2 - 0)'08-07-30 Universitario - Deportivo Quito (0 - 0)'08-04-09 Guadalajara - Santos FC (3 - 2)'08-02-26 Caracas FC - Real Potosí (2 - 1)'07-08-30 England u17 - Syria u17 (3 - 1)'07-08-23 USA u17 - Tunisia u17 (1 - 3)'07-07-07 Spain u20 - Jordan u20 (4 - 2)'07-07-05 Austria u20 - Canada u20 (1 - 0)'07-07-02 Portugal u20 - New Zealand u20 (2 - 0)'07-06-11 Japan u20 - Czech Republic u20 (2 - 2)'07-04-03 El Nacional - Banfield (0 - 1)'07-03-20 Caracas FC - Colo-Colo (0 - 4)'07-03-12 Brazil u17 - Ecuador u17 (4 - 5)'07-03-08 Peru u17 - Chile u17 (1 - 3)'06-08-23 Deportes Tolima - Ind. Medellin (3 - 1)

All matches

(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)

CONMEBOL COPA LIBERTADORES 2009 group stage:
Univ. San Martin - River Plate, 2 - 1. Alejandro Villanueva, Lima, Peru, 2009-03-05

A referee has to be as neutral as possible, and also consistent, if he wants to do a good job. Buitrago was not neutral, because he made a big mistake when he conceded a non-existent penalty to San Martín. Later, one or two similar situations in the other side, didn´t meant the same decision by the referee.

Penalty
Buitrago influenced the result, by giving San Martín the chance to score after a Peruvian player fell down inside River area. That wasn´t a penalty, in fact - in my opinion - wasn´t even a doubtful action. But with that goal, San Martín won the match.Later, Falcao was pushed inside the area... it was also doubtful, but this one was a bigger penalty than the other. The Colombian just said "go on!".

And
SM was a bit better during the 1st half and River was definitely better during the 2nd, but could not tie. Buitrago used 8 cards, often OK, often because of childish things. He seemed to have refereed the 2nd half knowing that he had made a mistake with that penalty, because he looked serious but he wasn´t really in control.

From our reporter: Sheriff