William Collum matches

Home - Referees - William Collum


© scottishfa.co.uk
 
Date
2014-02-25
Match
Zenit-Dortmund
 
-
Result
2 - 4
Referee decisions
Yellow
2 - 1
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
1 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
7.1
7.4
Members:
4
6.6
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
7.4
Control:
5.7
Calls:
7.2
Style:
8.5
Fitness:
8.3
Positioning:
7.4
General assessment
 
Reports for this match (2)
1) report by gefluegel
7.0
Control: Looked nervous and not fully in control
5.0
Calls: The 2:1 for Zenit was preceded by an clear offside, the penalty was a fata morgana - two marks go for this.
6.5
Style: Hmmm. Two mistakes which were rather evident, not convinced.
7.5
Fitness: Not a problem.
7.5
Positioning: Yep.
6.7
General assessment
Not up to the so-often cited "expected level". A class below Elite at least.
William Collum matches
'18-04-26 Marseille - Salzburg (2 - 0)'18-04-11 Bayern Munich - Sevilla FC (0 - 0)'18-03-23 Germany - Spain (1 - 1)'18-02-21 Shakhtar - AS Roma (2 - 1)'17-11-21 Spartak Moskva - Maribor (1 - 1)'17-10-18 Barcelona - Olympiakos (3 - 1)'17-10-07 Bosnia-Herzegovina - Belgium (3 - 4)'17-09-26 Napoli - Feyenoord (3 - 1)'17-09-05 Iceland - Ukraine (2 - 0)'17-08-22 Sevilla FC - Istanbul Başakşehir (2 - 2)'17-04-20 Genk - Celta de Vigo (1 - 1)'17-03-25 Bulgaria - Netherlands (2 - 0)'17-02-21 Leverkusen - Atlético de Madrid (2 - 4)'16-11-22 Sporting - Real Madrid (1 - 2)'16-10-19 Bayern Munich - PSV (4 - 1)'16-09-13 Dynamo Kyiv - Napoli (1 - 2)'16-09-04 Norway - Germany (0 - 3)'16-08-16 Ajax - Rostov (1 - 1)'16-06-21 Czech Republic - Turkey (0 - 2)'16-06-15 France - Albania (2 - 0)'16-03-17 Leverkusen - Villarreal (0 - 0)'15-11-25 Malmö - PSG (0 - 5)'15-10-21 Galatasaray - Benfica (2 - 1)'15-10-10 Azerbaijan - Italy (1 - 3)'15-09-16 AA Gent - Lyon (1 - 1)'15-09-04 Denmark - Albania (0 - 0)'15-08-19 Basel - Maccabi Tel Aviv (2 - 2)'15-08-11 Barcelona - Sevilla FC (5 - 4)'15-07-29 Rapid Wien - Ajax (2 - 2)'15-06-12 Iceland - Czech Republic (2 - 1)'15-04-22 Monaco - Juventus (0 - 0)'15-03-31 Netherlands - Spain (2 - 0)'15-03-11 Bayern Munich - Shakhtar (7 - 0)'14-12-09 Juventus - Atlético de Madrid (0 - 0)'14-11-18 Austria - Brazil (1 - 2)'14-11-15 Montenegro - Sweden (1 - 1)'14-10-21 Barcelona - Ajax (3 - 1)'14-10-11 Romania - Hungary (1 - 1)'14-09-30 CSKA Moskva - Bayern Munich (0 - 1)'14-08-26 APOEL - AaB (4 - 0)'14-04-03 Lyon - Juventus (0 - 1)• '14-02-25 Zenit - Dortmund (2 - 4)'13-11-27 Real Madrid - Galatasaray (4 - 1)'13-11-05 Shakhtar - Leverkusen (0 - 0)'13-10-15 Sweden - Germany (3 - 5)'13-09-18 Atlético de Madrid - Zenit (3 - 1)'13-08-27 Basel - Ludogorets Razgrad (2 - 0)'13-06-07 Albania - Norway (1 - 1)'13-05-29 England - Ireland (1 - 1)'13-04-04 Fenerbahce SK - Lazio (2 - 0)'13-02-20 Galatasaray - Schalke 04 (1 - 1)'12-12-05 Bayern Munich - BATE (4 - 1)'12-11-14 Poland - Uruguay (1 - 3)'12-11-07 CFR Cluj - Galatasaray (1 - 3)'12-10-16 Slovakia - Greece (0 - 1)'12-10-12 France - Japan (0 - 1)'12-09-18 AC Milan - Anderlecht (0 - 0)'12-08-22 VfB Stuttgart - Dinamo Moskva (2 - 0)'12-04-05 Metalist Kharkiv - Sporting (1 - 1)'12-03-15 PSV - Valencia (1 - 1)'12-02-23 Club Brugge - Hannover (0 - 1)'11-12-06 Barcelona - BATE (4 - 0)'11-11-03 AEK - Lokomotiv Moskva (1 - 3)'11-10-11 Norway - Cyprus (3 - 1)'11-09-14 Basel - Otelul (2 - 1)'11-09-06 Belgium - USA (1 - 0)'11-08-03 Saudi Arabia u20 - Guatemala u20 (6 - 0)'11-07-30 Cameroon u20 - New Zealand u20 (1 - 1)'11-04-14 Twente - Villarreal (1 - 3)'11-03-26 Bulgaria - Switzerland (0 - 0)'11-03-17 PSG - Benfica (1 - 1)'11-02-24 Leverkusen - Metalist Kharkiv (2 - 0)'10-12-08 CFR Cluj - AS Roma (1 - 1)'10-10-24 Celtic - Glasgow Rangers (1 - 3)'10-10-20 Schalke 04 - Hapoel Tel Aviv (3 - 1)'10-10-12 Croatia u21 - Spain u21 (0 - 3)'10-09-29 Panathinaikos - Kobenhavn (0 - 2)'10-09-03 France - Belarus (0 - 1)'10-08-26 Juventus - Sturm Graz (1 - 0)'10-07-27 Dynamo Kyiv - AA Gent (3 - 0)'10-02-18 Rubin Kazan - Hapoel Tel Aviv (3 - 0)'09-12-17 Lazio - Levski Sofia (0 - 1)'09-11-05 Nacional CD - Athletic Bilbao (1 - 1)'09-10-10 Norway - South Africa (1 - 0)'09-10-01 Shakhtar - Partizan (4 - 1)'09-09-09 Slovenia - Poland (3 - 0)'09-08-20 PAOK - Heerenveen (1 - 1)'09-08-05 Stabæk - Kobenhavn (0 - 0)'09-05-29 Nigeria - Ireland (1 - 1)'09-02-26 VfB Stuttgart - Zenit (1 - 2)'08-12-03 Metalist Kharkiv - Olympiakos (1 - 0)'08-11-18 Germany u21 - Italy u21 (1 - 0)'08-10-11 Finland - Azerbaijan (1 - 0)'08-09-18 Rennes - Twente (2 - 1)'08-08-06 Dinamo Zagreb - Domzale (3 - 2)'08-07-23 Germany u19 - Italy u19 (3 - 1)'08-07-20 Italy u19 - Czech Republic u19 (4 - 3)'08-07-14 Germany u19 - Spain u19 (2 - 1)'07-10-23 Liechtenstein u19 - Albania u19 (0 - 0)'07-10-20 Albania u19 - Serbia u19 (2 - 1)'07-10-17 Andorra - Estonia (0 - 2)'07-09-08 Switzerland u21 - Macedonia u21 (1 - 1)'07-08-16 Leiria - M. Netanya (0 - 0)'07-07-24 BATE - APOEL (3 - 0)'07-07-08 Honka Espoo - AaB (2 - 2)'06-10-02 Slovakia u19 - Russia u19 (1 - 0)'06-09-29 Russia u19 - Albania u19 (2 - 0)'06-08-24 Domzale - Hapoel Tel Aviv (0 - 3)'06-06-25 Kalmar - Trans Narva (2 - 0)'06-06-09 Armenia u21 - San Marino u21 (4 - 0)'06-05-11 Germany u17 - Russia u17 (0 - 1)'06-05-05 Germany u17 - Czech Republic u17 (0 - 0)'06-05-03 Hungary u17 - Russia u17 (0 - 1)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)



Other Encounters

The Dallas Connection?

UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE 2013 - 2014 round of 16:
Zenit - Dortmund, 2 - 4. Petrovsky, St Petersburg, Russia, 2014-02-25

Last season it was the hapless Thomson to mishandle the CL quarter finals match between Dortmund and Malaga. This time around we had the shambolic Collum to officiate in St. Petersburg. You don't have to resort to conspiracy therories in order to questio, how comes thes inept Scots get that high in UEFA referees rankings. I suppose Hugh Dallas, one of the most influential persons serving in the referees committee, is behind these awkward nominations.

The game
Borussia Dortmund were in the saddle from start to end. Actually, two very early goals (minutes 4' and 5') clinched the encounter in the very early stages. When Zenit made noises of coming back into it (57' and 69, respectively). Borussia were alert, responded quickly and maintained their safe lead (61' and 71'. respectively).

The Zenit's goals
Both Zenit's goal were due to refereeing errors. Otherwise, they probably wouldn't have scored any. Their first goal came after a sequence of two offsides undetected by ar Cryans - the first one a clearly active offside, as the ball was conrolled and played by a forward who had been offside beforehand, the second one should have been deemed offside, as the offside player interfered with a defender who tried to clear the ball. The second goal came from a converted penalty-kick, which should have never been awarded. Worse than that, Piszczek who was adjudged committing the foul that never was (a tackle clean as a whistle), was shown the yellow card.

Mr. Collum
The referee could have had the easiest of evenings as the final result was actually settled five minutes into the game. But he underpeformed, his foul-detection was questionable in midfield, and as mentioned above, compounded them with the atrocious penalty-box blunder. There were not too many replays, thus From what could be seen in "real time", ar Conquer performed very well.

From our reporter: adir