William Collum matches

Home - Referees - William Collum


© scottishfa.co.uk
 
Date
2010-10-20
Match
Schalke 04-Hapoel Tel Aviv
 
-
Result
3 - 1
Referee decisions
Yellow
1 - 1
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
7.6
7.4
Members:
6
6.6
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
7.0
Control: Lacking a bit in authority
7.0
Calls: There is room for improvement
9.9
Neutrality:
8.0
Style:
8.0
General assessment
 
Reports for this match (2)
1) report by Niclas E
7.0
Control: all right
6.0
Calls: sometimes a bit confusing, must book hapoel's player for handball in 12th minute. no penalty was correct, very pedantic: he whistled actions that are not a foul in the u15
8.0
Neutrality: all right
7.0
Style: ok
7.0
General assessment
to my mind, convincing perfomance but he is 32, he must still learn
William Collum matches
'18-04-26 Marseille - Salzburg (2 - 0)'18-04-11 Bayern Munich - Sevilla FC (0 - 0)'18-03-23 Germany - Spain (1 - 1)'18-02-21 Shakhtar - AS Roma (2 - 1)'17-11-21 Spartak Moskva - Maribor (1 - 1)'17-10-18 Barcelona - Olympiakos (3 - 1)'17-10-07 Bosnia-Herzegovina - Belgium (3 - 4)'17-09-26 Napoli - Feyenoord (3 - 1)'17-09-05 Iceland - Ukraine (2 - 0)'17-08-22 Sevilla FC - Istanbul Başakşehir (2 - 2)'17-04-20 Genk - Celta de Vigo (1 - 1)'17-03-25 Bulgaria - Netherlands (2 - 0)'17-02-21 Leverkusen - Atlético de Madrid (2 - 4)'16-11-22 Sporting - Real Madrid (1 - 2)'16-10-19 Bayern Munich - PSV (4 - 1)'16-09-13 Dynamo Kyiv - Napoli (1 - 2)'16-09-04 Norway - Germany (0 - 3)'16-08-16 Ajax - Rostov (1 - 1)'16-06-21 Czech Republic - Turkey (0 - 2)'16-06-15 France - Albania (2 - 0)'16-03-17 Leverkusen - Villarreal (0 - 0)'15-11-25 Malmö - PSG (0 - 5)'15-10-21 Galatasaray - Benfica (2 - 1)'15-10-10 Azerbaijan - Italy (1 - 3)'15-09-16 AA Gent - Lyon (1 - 1)'15-09-04 Denmark - Albania (0 - 0)'15-08-19 Basel - Maccabi Tel Aviv (2 - 2)'15-08-11 Barcelona - Sevilla FC (5 - 4)'15-07-29 Rapid Wien - Ajax (2 - 2)'15-06-12 Iceland - Czech Republic (2 - 1)'15-04-22 Monaco - Juventus (0 - 0)'15-03-31 Netherlands - Spain (2 - 0)'15-03-11 Bayern Munich - Shakhtar (7 - 0)'14-12-09 Juventus - Atlético de Madrid (0 - 0)'14-11-18 Austria - Brazil (1 - 2)'14-11-15 Montenegro - Sweden (1 - 1)'14-10-21 Barcelona - Ajax (3 - 1)'14-10-11 Romania - Hungary (1 - 1)'14-09-30 CSKA Moskva - Bayern Munich (0 - 1)'14-08-26 APOEL - AaB (4 - 0)'14-04-03 Lyon - Juventus (0 - 1)'14-02-25 Zenit - Dortmund (2 - 4)'13-11-27 Real Madrid - Galatasaray (4 - 1)'13-11-05 Shakhtar - Leverkusen (0 - 0)'13-10-15 Sweden - Germany (3 - 5)'13-09-18 Atlético de Madrid - Zenit (3 - 1)'13-08-27 Basel - Ludogorets Razgrad (2 - 0)'13-06-07 Albania - Norway (1 - 1)'13-05-29 England - Ireland (1 - 1)'13-04-04 Fenerbahce SK - Lazio (2 - 0)'13-02-20 Galatasaray - Schalke 04 (1 - 1)'12-12-05 Bayern Munich - BATE (4 - 1)'12-11-14 Poland - Uruguay (1 - 3)'12-11-07 CFR Cluj - Galatasaray (1 - 3)'12-10-16 Slovakia - Greece (0 - 1)'12-10-12 France - Japan (0 - 1)'12-09-18 AC Milan - Anderlecht (0 - 0)'12-08-22 VfB Stuttgart - Dinamo Moskva (2 - 0)'12-04-05 Metalist Kharkiv - Sporting (1 - 1)'12-03-15 PSV - Valencia (1 - 1)'12-02-23 Club Brugge - Hannover (0 - 1)'11-12-06 Barcelona - BATE (4 - 0)'11-11-03 AEK - Lokomotiv Moskva (1 - 3)'11-10-11 Norway - Cyprus (3 - 1)'11-09-14 Basel - Otelul (2 - 1)'11-09-06 Belgium - USA (1 - 0)'11-08-03 Saudi Arabia u20 - Guatemala u20 (6 - 0)'11-07-30 Cameroon u20 - New Zealand u20 (1 - 1)'11-04-14 Twente - Villarreal (1 - 3)'11-03-26 Bulgaria - Switzerland (0 - 0)'11-03-17 PSG - Benfica (1 - 1)'11-02-24 Leverkusen - Metalist Kharkiv (2 - 0)'10-12-08 CFR Cluj - AS Roma (1 - 1)'10-10-24 Celtic - Glasgow Rangers (1 - 3)• '10-10-20 Schalke 04 - Hapoel Tel Aviv (3 - 1)'10-10-12 Croatia u21 - Spain u21 (0 - 3)'10-09-29 Panathinaikos - Kobenhavn (0 - 2)'10-09-03 France - Belarus (0 - 1)'10-08-26 Juventus - Sturm Graz (1 - 0)'10-07-27 Dynamo Kyiv - AA Gent (3 - 0)'10-02-18 Rubin Kazan - Hapoel Tel Aviv (3 - 0)'09-12-17 Lazio - Levski Sofia (0 - 1)'09-11-05 Nacional CD - Athletic Bilbao (1 - 1)'09-10-10 Norway - South Africa (1 - 0)'09-10-01 Shakhtar - Partizan (4 - 1)'09-09-09 Slovenia - Poland (3 - 0)'09-08-20 PAOK - Heerenveen (1 - 1)'09-08-05 Stabæk - Kobenhavn (0 - 0)'09-05-29 Nigeria - Ireland (1 - 1)'09-02-26 VfB Stuttgart - Zenit (1 - 2)'08-12-03 Metalist Kharkiv - Olympiakos (1 - 0)'08-11-18 Germany u21 - Italy u21 (1 - 0)'08-10-11 Finland - Azerbaijan (1 - 0)'08-09-18 Rennes - Twente (2 - 1)'08-08-06 Dinamo Zagreb - Domzale (3 - 2)'08-07-23 Germany u19 - Italy u19 (3 - 1)'08-07-20 Italy u19 - Czech Republic u19 (4 - 3)'08-07-14 Germany u19 - Spain u19 (2 - 1)'07-10-23 Liechtenstein u19 - Albania u19 (0 - 0)'07-10-20 Albania u19 - Serbia u19 (2 - 1)'07-10-17 Andorra - Estonia (0 - 2)'07-09-08 Switzerland u21 - Macedonia u21 (1 - 1)'07-08-16 Leiria - M. Netanya (0 - 0)'07-07-24 BATE - APOEL (3 - 0)'07-07-08 Honka Espoo - AaB (2 - 2)'06-10-02 Slovakia u19 - Russia u19 (1 - 0)'06-09-29 Russia u19 - Albania u19 (2 - 0)'06-08-24 Domzale - Hapoel Tel Aviv (0 - 3)'06-06-25 Kalmar - Trans Narva (2 - 0)'06-06-09 Armenia u21 - San Marino u21 (4 - 0)'06-05-11 Germany u17 - Russia u17 (0 - 1)'06-05-05 Germany u17 - Czech Republic u17 (0 - 0)'06-05-03 Hungary u17 - Russia u17 (0 - 1)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)



Other Encounters

Not bad

UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE 2010-2011 group stage:
Schalke 04 - Hapoel Tel Aviv, 3 - 1. Arena AufSchalke, Gelsenkirchen, Germany, 2010-10-20

After Raul had scored his and Schalke`s second goal (58`), the final whistle could have been heard as the next 35 minutes were more kind of "garbage time" as Hapoel seemed lost and bereft of stamina.

Referee and assistants
Coming January Mr. collum will celebrate his 32nd birthday - a young lad indeed, compared to some veterans who haven`t yet experienced a CL match (it was Collum`s second this season). And as his looks are also of a youngster (though balding), it wasn`t easy for him to stamp his authority on the Schalke players. Sometimes players argued with him, he turned a blind eye to Raul blocking an Hapoel free kick while being much less than 9.15 m from the ball when the kick was taken (41`), etc. His foul calls and non-calls are also to be improved, Assistant referee, Mr. Drummond made some mistakes, especially not contributing to the flow of the game by raising his flag for fouls, thus prohibiting the player and team from getting an advantage without game stoppage (for instance minutes 67 and 72 - in the second case, Mr. Collum preferred the advantage rule and didn`t blow his whistle). No grudges about Mr Sorbie`s assistance.

From our reporter: adir