Mark Clattenburg matches

Home - Referees - Mark Clattenburg


© 
 
Date
2014-03-05
Match
Germany-Chile
 
-
Result
1 - 0
Referee decisions
Yellow
0 - 1
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
8
7.8
Members:
6
7.5
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
7.9
Control: Controlled the match by whistling quite often. For my taste, a bit too often.
7.9
Calls: As he used a narrow scope for foulplay a bit arbitrary on his decisions what he would allow and what he would let go in a different moment.
8.1
Style: Rather unenglish I felt. Hmm, but no complaints.
8.2
Fitness: English lads are never unfit even if they have been to the pub the night before.
8.1
Positioning: Close to play, not a prob.
8.0
General assessment
Mark Clattenburg is a different kid on the block in comparison to Webb and other referees from the UK in my mind. On the night, he was okayish, whistled for my taste a bit too often and showed an "expected level" display without great challenges. 
Mark Clattenburg matches
'17-03-28 Estonia - Croatia (3 - 0)'17-03-16 Borussia Mönchengladbach - Schalke 04 (2 - 2)'16-11-22 Sevilla FC - Juventus (1 - 3)'16-11-15 Northern Ireland - Croatia (0 - 3)'16-11-01 Besiktas - Napoli (1 - 1)'16-10-20 Kuban Krasnodar - Schalke 04 (0 - 1)'16-10-09 Iceland - Turkey (2 - 0)'16-09-27 Dortmund - Real Madrid (2 - 2)'16-08-17 Ludogorets Razgrad - Plzen (2 - 0)'16-07-10 Portugal - France (1 - 0)'16-06-25 Switzerland - Poland (1 - 1)'16-06-17 Czech Republic - Croatia (2 - 2)'16-06-13 Belgium - Italy (0 - 2)'16-05-28 Real Madrid - Atlético de Madrid (1 - 1)'16-04-27 Atlético de Madrid - Bayern Munich (1 - 0)'16-04-07 Athletic Bilbao - Sevilla FC (1 - 2)'16-03-15 Atlético de Madrid - PSV (0 - 0)'16-02-25 Porto - Dortmund (0 - 1)'15-12-09 Leverkusen - Barcelona (1 - 1)'15-11-12 Norway - Hungary (0 - 1)'15-11-03 Real Madrid - PSG (1 - 0)'15-10-13 Malta - Croatia (0 - 1)'15-10-08 Portugal - Denmark (1 - 0)'15-09-29 BATE - AS Roma (3 - 2)'15-09-05 Russia - Sweden (1 - 0)'15-08-19 Valencia - Monaco (3 - 1)'15-05-12 Bayern Munich - Barcelona (3 - 2)'15-04-15 PSG - Barcelona (1 - 3)'15-03-31 Israel - Belgium (0 - 1)'15-03-19 Internazionale - Wolfsburg (1 - 2)'15-02-18 Basel - Porto (1 - 1)'14-11-25 Shakhtar - Athletic Bilbao (0 - 1)'14-11-16 Cyprus - Andorra (5 - 0)'14-11-04 Malmö - Atlético de Madrid (0 - 2)'14-10-01 Zenit - Monaco (0 - 0)'14-09-07 Greece - Romania (0 - 1)'14-08-27 Leverkusen - Kobenhavn (4 - 0)'14-08-12 Real Madrid - Sevilla FC (2 - 0)'14-06-07 USA - Nigeria (2 - 1)'14-06-01 Sweden - Belgium (0 - 2)'14-05-26 Russia - Slovakia (1 - 0)'14-05-01 Juventus - Benfica (0 - 0)'14-04-02 Real Madrid - Dortmund (3 - 0)'14-03-11 Atlético de Madrid - AC Milan (0 - 1)• '14-03-05 Germany - Chile (1 - 0)'13-12-10 Benfica - PSG (2 - 1)'13-11-14 Belgium - Colombia (0 - 2)'13-10-25 Argentina u17 - Canada u17 (3 - 0)'13-10-20 UAE u17 - Brazil u17 (1 - 6)'13-09-17 Galatasaray - Real Madrid (1 - 6)'13-08-28 AC Milan - PSV (3 - 0)'13-04-02 Bayern Munich - Juventus (2 - 0)'13-03-26 Netherlands - Romania (4 - 0)'13-02-19 Porto - Malaga (1 - 0)'12-12-06 Genk - Basel (0 - 0)'12-10-23 Spartak Moskva - Benfica (2 - 1)'12-09-18 Malaga - Zenit (3 - 0)'12-09-11 Israel - Russia (0 - 4)'12-08-30 Bordeaux - Crvena Zvezda (3 - 2)'12-08-11 Brazil OT - Mexico OT (1 - 2)'12-08-04 Mexico OT - Senegal OT (4 - 2)'12-07-29 Egypt OT - New Zealand OT (1 - 1)'12-04-05 Hannover - Atlético de Madrid (1 - 2)'12-03-13 Bayern Munich - Basel (7 - 0)'12-02-16 Steaua - Twente (0 - 1)'11-12-07 Dinamo Zagreb - Lyon (1 - 7)'11-10-18 CSKA Moskva - Trabzonspor (3 - 0)'11-10-11 Ghana - Nigeria (0 - 0)'11-10-07 Finland - Sweden (1 - 3)'11-09-27 Real Madrid - Ajax (3 - 0)'11-08-17 Brazil u20 - Mexico u20 (2 - 0)'11-08-09 Colombia u20 - Costa Rica u20 (3 - 2)'11-08-04 Brazil u20 - Panama u20 (4 - 0)'11-07-30 Mali u20 - Korea Republic u20 (0 - 2)'11-06-06 Ukraine - France (1 - 4)'11-03-10 Twente - Zenit (3 - 0)'11-02-17 Napoli - Villarreal (0 - 0)'10-12-15 Dinamo Zagreb - PAOK (0 - 1)'10-11-03 Auxerre - Ajax (2 - 1)'10-10-09 Netherlands u21 - Ukraine u21 (1 - 3)'10-09-16 Aris Thessaloniki - Atlético de Madrid (1 - 0)'10-09-03 Portugal - Cyprus (4 - 4)'10-08-19 Galatasaray - Karpaty Lviv (2 - 2)'10-08-04 Kobenhavn - BATE (3 - 2)'10-07-13 Hapoel Tel Aviv - Zeljeznicar (5 - 0)'10-06-05 Ghana - Latvia (1 - 0)'09-11-13 Hungary u21 - Italy u21 (2 - 0)'09-08-20 Ajax - Slovan Bratislava (5 - 0)'09-08-01 Arsenal - Atlético de Madrid (2 - 1)'09-07-30 Frederikstad - Lech Poznan (1 - 6)'09-07-16 Anorthosis - Petrovac (2 - 1)'08-08-03 Arsenal - Real Madrid (1 - 0)'08-07-12 Neftchi Baku - Germinal Beerschot (1 - 0)'08-05-29 Ireland - Colombia (1 - 0)'08-02-14 Rosenborg - Fiorentina (0 - 1)'07-11-29 Hamburger SV - Rennes (3 - 0)'07-11-17 Australia - Nigeria (1 - 0)'07-10-25 Lokomotiv Moskva - Atlético de Madrid (3 - 3)'07-10-04 Ajax - Dinamo Zagreb (2 - 3)'07-09-12 Denmark - Liechtenstein (4 - 0)'07-08-30 Lens - Young Boys (5 - 1)'07-02-07 Netherlands - Russia (4 - 1)'06-11-14 Australia - Ghana (1 - 1)'06-10-09 Portugal u19 - Norway u19 (2 - 2)'06-10-04 Portugal u19 - Latvia u19 (1 - 0)'06-09-05 Denmark u21 - Sweden u21 (0 - 2)'06-08-24 Vaduz - Basel (2 - 1)'06-07-27 Omonia - Rijeka (2 - 1)'06-07-16 Hertha BSC - Moskva FK (0 - 0)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)

The Low illness

---- FRIENDLY :
Germany - Chile, 1 - 0. VfB Arena, Stuttgart, Germany, 2014-03-05

Since 1996 Germany has not won an international title. Since the Home WC in 2006 Joachim Low is the German manager having been the tactical brain under Klinsmann beforehand. On the positive side, he has endorsed a very positive approach to attacking football in comparison to the 80ies, 90ies, and 2002 when Germany played rather cynical but won important matches. The negative side is a very weak defence when playing big names and if he doesn't win an international title in Brasil, his era will come to a close with a succession of final and semifinal defeats.

This match tactically
Why has Germany not beaten any of the really big names like Spain or Italy in a match at competition level? Because defensively they are weak, despite having a good goalkeeper behind and if you find a way to counter their tactical plan, they are lost. Chili exposed the Low illness perfectly in this match and although it was said in post-match-analysis that Chili are a major force in South American football this is not true for the way Germany thinks about that. Chili played forechecking very deep, had high pace on and off the ball and had they shown more finishing skills they would have won it. Germany scored once and dominated for 20 minutes in the first half, but was then unseen for most of the second half. They were poor, but they talked their way out of it afterward - with a display like this the first round at the WC will be the ultimate finishing point for the "Mannschaft".

Clattenburg in all this
Mike Clattenburg is in my opinion an un-english referee in the sense that he is not so much a match-flow orientated official than many others form the UK. He whistles quite often for minor offences which made it difficult for me to see his threshold which seemed to vary. This was not a difficult match for him, he gave one yellow for a foul from behind (spot on) and he showed a good physical condition. The Germans got more and more frustrated at their own play, lost patience and the relatively narrow scope for a friendly by Clattenburg added to their sheer lack of ideas to do anything about the domination by Chili in half two.

Compared to Webb
If we compare him to Webb, he seems to be the more pro-active referee who will not wait so long to use cards or get a grip on the match by whistling more often. He talks much less and relies not so much on his presence but I'm not sure if he is the better official. To be honest, I have not seen enough of him to really judge - on this night he was alright in an uninspiring match. Therefore 8,0.

From our reporter: gefluegel