Roberto Rosetti matches


Roberto Rosetti has his doubts
© international hazma
 
Date
2008-11-25
Match
Villarreal-Manchester United
 
-
Result
0 - 0
Referee decisions
Yellow
3 - 2
Red
1 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Our marks
8.3
7.2
Your marks
8.3
7.2
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmarès Matches by tournament Forum
8
Control: Strict, firm, fair
9
Calls: Accurate, if occasionally pedantic
8
Neutrality:
8
Style: Pretty good
8.3
General assessment
Very good overall - this is why they gave him the Euro 2008 final 
Other reports for this match (1)
1) report by jinx
9
Control:
8
Calls:
8
Neutrality:
8
Style:
8.3
General assessment
rosetti is one of the few who dares to show direct red
Roberto Rosetti matches
'10-06-27 Argentina - Mexico (2 - 0)'10-06-19 Ghana - Australia (1 - 1)'10-04-21 Bayern Munich - Lyon (1 - 0)'09-12-15 Pohang Steelers - Estudiantes (1 - 2)'09-11-24 Glasgow Rangers - VfB Stuttgart (0 - 2)'09-11-18 Bosnia-Herzegovina - Portugal (0 - 1)'09-10-21 Wolfsburg - Besiktas (0 - 0)'09-10-10 Brazil u20 - Germany u20 (2 - 1)'09-10-02 Korea Republic u20 - USA u20 (3 - 0)'09-09-29 Uruguay u20 - Uzbekistan u20 (3 - 0)'09-09-25 Nigeria u20 - Venezuela u20 (0 - 1)'09-09-09 Serbia - France (1 - 1)'09-08-26 VfB Stuttgart - Timisoara (0 - 0)'09-05-05 Arsenal - Manchester United (1 - 3)'09-04-14 Bayern Munich - Barcelona (1 - 1)'09-03-28 Israel - Greece (1 - 1)'09-02-25 Real Madrid - Liverpool (0 - 1)• '08-11-25 Villarreal - Manchester United (0 - 0)'08-11-05 Arsenal - Fenerbahce SK (0 - 0)'08-10-11 Sweden - Portugal (0 - 0)'08-09-16 PSV - Atlético de Madrid (0 - 3)'08-08-27 Dynamo Kyiv - Spartak Moskva (4 - 1)'08-06-29 Germany - Spain (0 - 1)'08-06-20 Croatia - Turkey (1 - 1)'08-06-14 Greece - Russia (0 - 1)'08-06-07 Switzerland - Czech Republic (0 - 1)'08-04-30 Chelsea F.C. - Liverpool (3 - 2)'08-04-09 Barcelona - Schalke 04 (1 - 0)'08-03-04 Manchester United - Lyon (1 - 0)'07-11-28 Liverpool - Porto (4 - 1)'07-11-17 Spain - Sweden (3 - 0)'07-10-23 Sevilla FC - Steaua (2 - 1)'07-10-03 Valencia - Chelsea F.C. (1 - 2)'07-09-08 Portugal - Poland (2 - 2)'07-08-29 Celtic - Spartak Moskva (1 - 1)'07-06-02 Australia - Uruguay (1 - 2)'07-04-11 Liverpool - PSV (1 - 0)'07-03-24 Czech Republic - Germany (1 - 2)'07-03-06 Chelsea F.C. - Porto (2 - 1)'06-11-21 Benfica - Kobenhavn (3 - 1)'06-10-17 Steaua - Real Madrid (1 - 4)'06-10-11 Croatia - England (2 - 0)'06-09-27 Werder Bremen - Barcelona (1 - 1)'06-09-12 Galatasaray - Bordeaux (0 - 0)'06-08-22 Maccabi Haifa - Liverpool (1 - 1)'06-06-27 Spain - France (1 - 3)'06-06-20 Paraguay - Trinidad and Tobago (2 - 0)'06-06-16 Argentina - Serbia and Montenegro (6 - 0)'06-06-11 Mexico - Iran (3 - 1)'06-03-30 Basel - Middlesbrough (2 - 0)'06-02-15 Schalke 04 - Espanyol (2 - 1)'05-11-24 Monaco - Hamburger SV (2 - 0)'05-10-18 Ajax - Thun (2 - 0)'05-10-12 Slovakia - Russia (0 - 0)'05-09-28 Anderlecht - Betis (0 - 1)'05-09-03 Switzerland - Israel (1 - 1)'05-06-26 Mexico - Argentina (1 - 1)'05-06-19 Mexico - Brazil (1 - 0)'05-06-15 Argentina - Tunisia (2 - 1)'05-04-14 AZ - Villarreal (1 - 1)'05-03-26 Georgia - Greece (1 - 3)'04-10-21 Panionios - Newcastle United (0 - 1)'04-10-09 Czech Republic - Romania (1 - 0)'04-09-30 Gençlerbirliği - Egaleo (1 - 1)'04-08-10 Schalke 04 - Liberec (2 - 1)'04-06-01 England - Japan (1 - 1)'04-04-28 Romania - Germany (5 - 1)'03-12-19 Spain u20 - Brazil u20 (0 - 1)'03-12-04 Brazil u20 - Australia u20 (2 - 3)'03-12-02 Korea Republic u20 - Paraguay u20 (0 - 1)'03-11-28 Panama u20 - Burkina Faso u20 (0 - 1)'03-11-15 Sweden u21 - Spain u21 (2 - 0)'03-11-06 Kobenhavn - Mallorca (1 - 2)'03-09-24 Sporting - Malmö (2 - 0)'03-06-11 Turkey - Macedonia (3 - 2)'02-10-15 Turkey u21 - Portugal u21 (4 - 2)'02-09-19 Ankaragücü - Alavés (1 - 2)'02-08-21 Switzerland - Austria (3 - 2)'02-08-15 Leixões - Belasica (2 - 2)'02-05-10 France u17 - Switzerland u17 (0 - 0)'02-05-01 England u17 - Denmark u17 (0 - 0)'02-04-28 Hungary u17 - Poland u17 (1 - 3)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)
UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE 2008-2009 group stage:
Villarreal - Manchester United, 0 - 0. El Madrigal, Villarreal, Spain, 2008-11-25

For the fourth meeting in a row Man Utd have drawn with Villareal. This game was a bit more exciting though; and United showed some of their true quality and class at times. Ronaldo was denied by a combination of Lopez and the crossbar. Rooney, Anderson and Fletcher all had good shots denied. A straight red for Villareal's Capdevila added to the drama late-on.

Strict but fair
Rosetti was, as per normal, quite strict. However, it would be hard to argue with any of his decisions. The players are reluctant to disagree with Rosetti, due to his physical presence and this allows him to control the game with ease. In fact, the only thing he missed was Rooney's blatant dive, which should have picked up a caution for unsporting behaviour.

In charge
When Rosetti referees you get the sense he has no idea who is playing - they are all just another player or another team to him. This allows him to supply the laws without fear or favour, and means he earns the respect of the teams. His accurate decision making also helps in this regard. As such Rosetti is in command on the field without intruding on the game too much.

Praise from Sir Alex
Alex Ferguson gave Rosetti high praise fr being strong throughout the match. He was referring mostly to the decision to dismiss Capdevila for a high and heavy tackle on Ronaldo.while this decision was unpopular with the home crowd, Rosetti was absolutely correct to brandish a second yellow followed by the red.

From our reporter: padre