Óscar Ruiz matches


© timeinc.net
 
Date
2007-07-10
Match
Uruguay-Brazil
 
-
Result
2 - 2
Referee decisions
Yellow
3 - 3
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Our marks
7
7.4
Your marks
6
7.3
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmarès Matches by tournament Forum
8
Control: No problems
7
Calls: Looked like a penalty for Brazil...
7
Neutrality: Last penalty should have been retaken
6
Style: I like it but not today
7
General assessment
Ruiz can referee much better. He's a very good ref; perhaps not his best moment now. 
Óscar Ruiz matches
'11-05-05 Cerro Porteno - Estudiantes (0 - 0)'11-04-25 Millonarios - Atlético Nacional (1 - 2)'11-04-19 Internacional - Emelec (2 - 0)'11-04-06 Nacional (UR) - Fluminense (2 - 0)'11-03-03 LDU Quito - Independiente (3 - 0)'11-02-15 América - Nacional (UR) (2 - 0)'10-12-08 Independiente - Goiás (3 - 1)'10-11-10 LDU Quito - Newell's Old Boys (1 - 0)'10-09-07 Argentina - Spain (4 - 1)'10-08-18 Internacional - Guadalajara (3 - 2)'10-06-22 France - South Africa (1 - 2)'10-06-17 Greece - Nigeria (2 - 1)'10-05-20 Estudiantes - Internacional (2 - 1)'10-05-12 Cruzeiro - Sao Paulo (0 - 2)'10-04-27 Guadalajara - Vélez Sarsfield (3 - 0)'10-04-13 Deportivo Quito - Cerro CA (2 - 1)'10-03-31 Monarcas Morelia - Banfield (1 - 1)'10-02-24 Cruzeiro - Colo-Colo (4 - 1)'10-02-10 Emelec - Newell's Old Boys (2 - 1)'09-11-19 LDU Quito - River Plate (Uruguay) (7 - 0)'09-10-09 Italy u20 - Hungary u20 (2 - 3)'09-10-02 Uzbekistan u20 - England u20 (1 - 1)'09-09-29 Korea Republic u20 - Germany u20 (1 - 1)'09-09-05 Argentina - Brazil (1 - 3)'09-07-02 Gremio - Cruzeiro (2 - 2)'09-06-18 Estudiantes - Defensor Sporting (1 - 0)'09-06-10 Brazil - Paraguay (2 - 1)'09-03-17 Ind. Medellin - América de Cali (0 - 0)'08-11-19 Internacional - Guadalajara (4 - 0)'08-11-06 Boca Juniors - Internacional (1 - 2)'08-10-15 Chile - Argentina (1 - 0)'08-09-16 Deportivo Cali - América de Cali (1 - 0)'08-09-10 Uruguay - Ecuador (0 - 0)'08-06-18 Brazil - Argentina (0 - 0)'08-05-14 Sao Paulo - Fluminense (1 - 0)'08-05-06 Estudiantes - LDU Quito (2 - 1)'08-04-17 River Plate - Univ. San Martin (5 - 0)'08-04-08 Atlas - Boca Juniors (3 - 1)'08-03-18 Caracas FC - Cruzeiro (1 - 1)'08-03-04 LDU Quito - Libertad (2 - 0)'07-12-05 Arsenal de Sarandí - América (1 - 2)'07-11-21 Chile - Paraguay (0 - 3)'07-10-25 Guadalajara - Arsenal de Sarandí (1 - 3)'07-10-17 Chile - Peru (2 - 0)'07-09-19 Botafogo - River Plate (1 - 0)• '07-07-10 Uruguay - Brazil (2 - 2)'07-06-27 Ecuador - Chile (2 - 3)'07-06-20 Gremio - Boca Juniors (0 - 2)'07-05-23 Santos FC - América (2 - 1)'07-05-17 Boca Juniors - Libertad (1 - 1)'07-04-24 Deportes Tolima - Cucuta Deportivo (3 - 4)'07-04-04 Cienciano - Boca Juniors (3 - 0)'07-03-06 El Nacional - Libertad (1 - 1)'06-12-14 América - Barcelona (0 - 4)'06-10-26 Gimnasia La Plata - Colo-Colo (0 - 2)'06-09-28 Fluminense - Gimnasia La Plata (1 - 1)'06-08-03 Internacional - Libertad (2 - 0)'06-07-14 Sao Paulo - Boca Juniors (2 - 2)'06-06-16 Netherlands - Cote d'Ivoire (2 - 1)'06-05-04 Goiás - Estudiantes (3 - 1)'06-04-27 Nacional (UR) - Internacional (1 - 2)'06-04-12 Libertad - Paulista (1 - 0)'06-03-08 River Plate - El Nacional (4 - 3)'06-02-07 LDU Quito - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 3)'06-02-01 Deportivo Tachira - Palmeiras (2 - 4)'06-01-29 USA - Norway (5 - 0)'05-11-23 Boca Juniors - Universidad Católica (2 - 2)'05-11-16 Bahrain - Trinidad and Tobago (0 - 1)'05-10-19 Corinthians - Pumas UNAM (2 - 1)'05-09-23 USA u17 - Cote d'Ivoire u17 (1 - 1)'05-09-19 Peru u17 - China u17 (0 - 1)'05-07-10 Mexico - Guatemala (4 - 0)'05-06-18 Nigeria u20 - Switzerland u20 (3 - 0)'05-06-14 USA u20 - Germany u20 (0 - 0)'05-06-10 Netherlands u20 - Japan u20 (2 - 1)'05-05-26 Cerro Porteno - Atletico Paranaense (2 - 1)'05-05-19 Universidad de Chile - Santos FC (2 - 1)'05-05-11 LDU Quito - Danubio (1 - 1)'05-04-28 The Strongest - Quilmes (2 - 1)'05-04-19 Deportivo Tachira - Cerro Porteno (0 - 3)'05-03-26 Chile - Uruguay (1 - 1)'05-03-16 Quilmes - Sao Paulo (2 - 2)'05-03-08 LDU Quito - Bolívar (1 - 0)'04-11-24 Boca Juniors - Internacional (4 - 2)'04-11-17 Ecuador - Brazil (1 - 0)'04-10-13 Paraguay - Peru (1 - 1)'04-06-18 Mexico - Brazil (0 - 4)'04-06-08 Costa Rica - Paraguay (0 - 1)'04-06-02 Brazil - Argentina (3 - 1)'04-05-11 América - Santo André (1 - 1)'04-05-05 LDU Quito - Santos FC (4 - 2)'04-04-13 Rosario Central - Olimpia Asuncion (2 - 1)'04-03-31 Paraguay - Brazil (0 - 0)'04-03-23 Sporting Cristal - Rosario Central (4 - 1)'04-02-18 Venezuela - Australia (1 - 1)'03-12-12 Japan u20 - Brazil u20 (1 - 5)'03-12-08 USA u20 - Cote d'Ivoire u20 (2 - 0)'03-12-04 UAE u20 - Burkina Faso u20 (0 - 0)'03-12-01 Mali u20 - Spain u20 (0 - 2)'03-11-16 Peru - Brazil (1 - 1)'03-09-10 Paraguay - Uruguay (4 - 1)'03-06-25 Boca Juniors - Santos FC (2 - 0)'03-05-21 Cruz Azul - Santos FC (2 - 2)'03-05-14 Corinthians - River Plate (1 - 2)'03-04-30 Mexico - Brazil (0 - 0)'03-04-22 Olimpia Asuncion - Gremio (2 - 3)'03-03-26 Alianza Lima - Gimnasia La Plata (1 - 1)'03-03-20 Pumas UNAM - Gremio (1 - 0)'03-02-11 Alianza Lima - Olimpia Asuncion (1 - 1)'02-08-21 Brazil - Paraguay (0 - 1)'02-07-16 América - Santo André (1 - 1)'02-07-10 Santo André - Olimpia Asuncion (1 - 2)'02-06-22 Senegal - Turkey (0 - 1)'02-06-13 Turkey - China (3 - 0)'02-06-04 Korea Republic - Poland (2 - 0)'02-05-14 Santo André - Peñarol (2 - 1)'02-05-02 Gremio - River Plate (4 - 0)'02-04-25 El Nacional - Boca Juniors (0 - 0)'02-04-11 Sporting Cristal - Monarcas Morelia (0 - 1)'02-03-13 América - River Plate (0 - 0)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)
CONMEBOL COPA AMERICA 2007 1/2 finals:
Uruguay - Brazil, 2 - 2. José Pachencho Romero, Maracaibo, Venezuela, 2007-07-10

Sometimes, looking back on a match, I can't find any big words to describe the referee's performance. Ruiz was not a disaster, he wasn't brilliant either... In fact, I think he did OK. But at the same time, his job hasn't convinced me. Well... this is how I feel now about Ruiz in this Uruguay - Brazil match (2 - 2 and 4 - 5 after penalties).

Intense
This was a real American Semi-Final match, with all its ingredients: nerves, discussions, big emotions, goals... Brazil and Uruguay made us feel, once again, all their football history. Especially the Uruguayans, they played THE match, and they did it well... much better than the pale - very defensive - Brazil. Sadly though, it wasn't enough for the Uruguayan "Celeste"...

Relaxed
During this battle, Ruiz had work to do. But from the beginning, I noticed that he was refereeing a bit indifferently. He's an experienced referee, of course, and this helps him. But today it seemed to me that he was TOO calm. During the game, he once or twice laughed with some players at something that we´ll never know... Well, I think he should have taken it more seriously.

But
But let's be fair: Ruiz did a good job. Doing a general evaluation, he was OK in the majority of the decisions he took. In the first half a foul on Vagner Love looked like a penalty for Brazil, but - as usual - Venezuelan TV didn't make things any clearer. In general, he used his cards correctly.

Penalties
During penalties, the officials must continue their work. The referee and the 1st assistant, they have two things to do: control if the ball has crossed the line, and prevent the goalkeeper from going forward... The Brazilian goalie did this once, twice... nobody even warned him. In the last penalty, the one that was missed by Lugano, Doni walked out 2 or 3 steps (1,5 m), and he stopped it. But, of course... would you have told the Brazilians that they had to repeat that last penalty?

From our reporter: Sheriff