WorldReferee.com - Andre El Haddad matches

Date

2011-10-26

Match

Jeonbuk Hyundai

Al Ittihad Jeddah

Result

2 - 1

Yellow

4 - 2

Red

1 - 1

Penalty

0 - 0

this match

overall

Our marks

5.2

5.7

Your marks

2.7

Matches Bio Did you know? Palmarès Matches by tournament

Reporter's marks

Control:

Calls:

Neutrality:

Style: I actually liked his style of dealing with fouls and dissent.

Other reports for this match (1)

1) report by Niclas E

Control:

Calls: first red yes, one can discuss whether the previous ellbow was red as well, I agree. The second yellow was the best joke of the year (AR2!!)

Neutrality:

Style:

I have seen now two performances of this referee. Both were very doubtful. Very doubtful. (CHN-SIN and now this perfomance), AFC did not publish the ref names, when I saw the players' and refs' entrance, I could not believe that they really appointed El Haddad..

Andre El Haddad matches

'13-05-14 Beijing Guoan - Seoul FC (0 - 0)'13-04-23 Esteghlal - Al Rayyan (3 - 0)'13-04-09 Muang Thong Utd - Guangzhou Evergrande (1 - 4)'13-04-02 El Jaish - Al Jazira (3 - 1)'13-02-26 Lekhwiya - Al Shabab al Arabi (2 - 1)'12-11-24 Vietnam - Myanmar (1 - 1)'12-10-02 Arbil - Chonburi FC (4 - 1)'12-09-19 Al Ittihad Jeddah - Guangzhou Evergrande (4 - 2)'12-07-03 Thailand u22 - Hong Kong u22 (4 - 0)'12-06-28 China u22 - Cambodia u22 (3 - 0)'12-06-23 Korea DPR u22 - Thailand u22 (4 - 2)'12-05-22 Al Ettifaq - Al Suwaiq (1 - 0)'12-05-16 Al Rayyan - Al Jazira (3 - 4)'12-04-17 Al Hilal (SA) - Al Shabab al Arabi (2 - 1)'12-04-04 Ulsan Hyundai - Brisbane Roar (1 - 1)'12-03-21 Guangzhou Evergrande - Buriram Utd (1 - 2)'12-03-06 Bunyodkor (Kuruvchi) - Adelaide United (1 - 2)'12-02-29 Bahrain - Indonesia (10 - 0)'11-12-20 Bahrain - Palestine (3 - 1)'11-11-22 Iraq OT - Australia OT (0 - 0)'11-11-11 Uzbekistan - Korea DPR (1 - 0)• '11-10-26 Jeonbuk Hyundai - Al Ittihad Jeddah (2 - 1)'11-09-13 Al Wahdat (jor) - Duhok FC (5 - 1)'11-09-02 China - Singapore (2 - 1)'11-06-19 Uzbekistan OT - Hong Kong OT (1 - 0)'11-05-25 Song Lam Nghe An - Persipura Jayapura (1 - 3)'11-05-11 Pakhtakor - Al Sadd SC (1 - 1)'11-05-03 Kashima Antlers - Shanghai Shenhua (2 - 0)'11-04-06 Al Rayyan - Zob Ahan (1 - 3)'11-03-16 Arema Malang - Jeonbuk Hyundai (0 - 4)'10-10-11 China u19 - Korea DPR u19 (0 - 2)'10-10-06 Japan u19 - Vietnam u19 (4 - 0)'10-10-04 Korea Republic u19 - Iran u19 (2 - 0)'10-04-21 Al Hilal (Yem) - Kuwait SC (0 - 2)'10-04-07 Al Riffa - Al Rayyan (1 - 4)'10-03-16 Saham - Ahli Sana'a (1 - 0)'10-02-27 Tajikistan - Myanmar (1 - 0)'10-02-21 Turkmenistan - Kyrgyzstan (1 - 0)'10-02-19 Kyrgyzstan - Korea DPR (0 - 4)'09-11-04 Tajikistan u19 - Jordan u19 (0 - 2)'09-10-27 Palestine u19 - Tajikistan u19 (0 - 3)'09-10-18 Iraq u16 - Palestine u16 (3 - 1)'09-10-10 Yemen u16 - Qatar u16 (2 - 1)'09-04-21 Home United - Club Valencia (5 - 1)'09-03-26 Nepal - Palestine (0 - 0)

All matches

(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)

AFC AFC CHAMPIONS LEAGUE 2011 1/2 final:
Jeonbuk Hyundai - Al Ittihad Jeddah, 2 - 1. Jeonju World Cup Stadium, Jeonju, Unknown, 2011-10-26

The Asian Football Confederation's Referee Committee has once again screwed up the assigning of important matches.

Assigning
In my opinion , El Heddad was not the best choice for this match, especially when you have referees like Nishimura, Irmatov and Subkheddin. His first match in the Champions League Knockout stage was a semi Final and he sure screwed it up.

First Red
It was very unfair to see the player from Al-ittihad be sent off after 12 minutes. Yes, he did deserve it for head butting the opponent but it was the Jeonbuk player who elbowed him in the face first. Both players should have been sent off but the referee made a huge mistake.

Second Red
The second red card of the match was a double yellow to a Joenbuk star who will now miss the Final because the referee made a mistake. A small tangle that happened in the 88th minute made the Referee show a second yellow to a Joenbuk player. Another big mistake by the officials. In this situation the Assistant Referee did not help the referee at all.

Result
The better team won the match and went through to the Final. Despite the fact, that the referee made two big mistakes, the better team won both legs but they are missing their star player for the final.

From our reporter: The ENG