Carlos Amarilla matches

Home - Referees - Carlos Amarilla


In action
© ard.de
 
Date
2009-10-14
Match
Uruguay-Argentina
 
-
Result
0 - 1
Referee decisions
Yellow
4 - 4
Red
2 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
4.6
6.5
Members:
6.4
6.2
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
6.0
Control: Yes but whistling permanently
4.0
Calls: Bad
5.0
Neutrality: ...
4.0
Style:
4.8
General assessment
I´m tired of Amarilla. Maybe FIFA could do without him during next World Cup? 
Reports for this match (5)
1) report by fctav
6.0
Control:
3.0
Calls:
4.0
Neutrality:
6.0
Style:
4.8
General assessment
Carlos Amarilla matches
'15-08-20 Emelec - Leon de Huanuco (3 - 0)'15-06-06 Colombia - Costa Rica (1 - 0)'15-05-06 Sao Paulo - Cruzeiro (1 - 0)'15-03-17 The Strongest - Universidad de Chile (5 - 3)'14-10-01 Bahia EC - Universidad Cesar Vallejo (2 - 0)'14-06-04 Chile - Northern Ireland (2 - 0)'14-04-16 León - Bolívar (2 - 2)'14-03-27 Indepediente Jose Teran - San Lorenzo (1 - 1)'14-03-13 Gremio - Newell's Old Boys (0 - 0)'13-09-18 Lanús - Universidad de Chile (4 - 0)'13-05-15 Corinthians - Boca Juniors (1 - 1)'13-05-09 Nacional (UR) - Real Garcilaso (1 - 0)'13-04-24 Brazil - Chile (2 - 2)'13-04-10 Tijuana - Millonarios (1 - 0)'13-03-07 Boca Juniors - Nacional (UR) (0 - 1)'13-02-20 Vélez Sarsfield - Deportes Iquique (3 - 0)'13-01-22 Tigres - Deportivo Anzoátegui (2 - 1)'12-10-24 Atletico Goianiense - Universidad Católica (3 - 1)'12-09-19 Brazil - Argentina (2 - 1)'12-09-11 Uruguay - Ecuador (1 - 1)'12-05-17 Vélez Sarsfield - Santos FC (1 - 0)'12-05-09 Lanús - Vasco da Gama (2 - 1)'12-04-04 Godoy Cruz - Universidad de Chile (0 - 1)'12-03-07 Boca Juniors - Fluminense (1 - 2)'12-02-21 Peñarol - Atlético Nacional (0 - 4)'11-11-09 Vasco da Gama - Universitario (5 - 2)'11-10-26 Universidad de Chile - Flamengo (1 - 0)'11-10-11 Bolivia - Colombia (1 - 2)'11-07-16 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 1)'11-07-08 Uruguay - Chile (1 - 1)'11-06-15 Peñarol - Santos FC (0 - 0)'11-06-04 Brazil - Netherlands (0 - 0)'11-05-26 Peñarol - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 0)'11-05-04 Universidad Católica - Gremio (1 - 0)'11-04-26 Vélez Sarsfield - LDU Quito (3 - 0)'11-04-06 América - Argentinos Juniors (2 - 1)'11-02-23 Fluminense - Nacional (UR) (0 - 0)'11-02-16 Cruzeiro - Estudiantes (5 - 0)'11-02-03 Union Espanola - Bolívar (0 - 0)'10-11-11 Independiente - Deportes Tolima (0 - 0)'10-10-20 Peñarol - Goiás (1 - 0)'10-08-25 Colo-Colo - Univ. de Sucre (3 - 1)'10-08-05 Sao Paulo - Internacional (2 - 1)'10-05-12 Flamengo - Universidad de Chile (2 - 3)'10-04-28 Flamengo - Corinthians (1 - 0)'10-04-22 Internacional - Deportivo Quito (3 - 0)'10-03-30 Juan Aurich - Estudiantes (0 - 2)'10-03-16 Colo-Colo - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 1)'10-02-24 Flamengo - Universidad Católica (2 - 0)'09-12-02 Fluminense - LDU Quito (3 - 0)'09-11-04 Italy u17 - USA u17 (2 - 1)'09-10-30 Germany u17 - Honduras u17 (3 - 1)'09-10-25 Turkey u17 - Burkina Faso u17 (1 - 0)• '09-10-14 Uruguay - Argentina (0 - 1)'09-09-30 Universidad de Chile - Internacional (1 - 0)'09-04-30 River Plate - Univ. San Martin (3 - 0)'09-04-22 Cruzeiro - Deportivo Quito (2 - 0)'09-04-15 Universidad de Chile - Gremio (0 - 2)'09-03-29 Peru - Chile (1 - 3)'09-03-18 Defensor Sporting - Sao Paulo (0 - 1)'09-03-12 Colo-Colo - LDU Quito (3 - 0)'09-02-19 Cruzeiro - Estudiantes (3 - 0)'08-11-26 Estudiantes - Internacional (0 - 1)'08-11-05 Argentinos Juniors - Palmeiras (2 - 0)'08-10-21 Estudiantes - Botafogo (2 - 0)'08-10-01 Internacional - Universidad Católica (0 - 0)'08-09-10 Peru - Argentina (1 - 1)'08-05-21 Fluminense - Sao Paulo (3 - 1)'08-05-08 Cucuta Deportivo - Santos FC (0 - 2)'08-04-15 Estudiantes - Deportivo Cuenca (2 - 0)'08-03-27 Boca Juniors - Colo-Colo (4 - 3)'08-03-19 Flamengo - Nacional (UR) (2 - 0)'08-03-13 América - Univ. San Martin (3 - 1)'08-03-04 Santos FC - Guadalajara (1 - 0)'08-02-21 San Lorenzo - Cruzeiro (0 - 0)'07-10-24 Vasco da Gama - América (1 - 0)'07-10-14 Colombia - Brazil (0 - 0)'07-09-27 River Plate - Botafogo (4 - 2)'07-09-19 Goiás - Arsenal de Sarandí (2 - 3)'07-07-15 Brazil - Argentina (3 - 0)'07-07-04 Mexico - Chile (0 - 0)'07-06-26 Uruguay - Peru (0 - 3)'07-05-31 Cucuta Deportivo - Boca Juniors (3 - 1)'07-05-23 Gremio - Defensor Sporting (2 - 0)'07-05-10 Santos FC - Caracas FC (3 - 2)'07-04-25 Sao Paulo - Audax Italiano (2 - 2)'07-04-03 Nacional (UR) - Emelec (3 - 1)'07-03-22 Boca Juniors - Toluca (3 - 0)'07-03-14 Vélez Sarsfield - Internacional (3 - 0)'06-07-07 Boca Juniors - Sao Paulo (2 - 1)'06-06-23 Ukraine - Tunisia (1 - 0)'06-06-19 Togo - Switzerland (0 - 2)'06-06-12 USA - Czech Republic (0 - 3)'06-04-26 River Plate - Corinthians (3 - 2)'06-04-18 Vélez Sarsfield - LDU Quito (2 - 2)'06-04-11 Union Espanola - Newell's Old Boys (1 - 1)'06-04-04 Nacional (UR) - Internacional (0 - 0)'06-02-22 Goiás - The Strongest (2 - 0)'05-12-18 Boca Juniors - Pumas UNAM (1 - 1)'05-11-10 Boca Juniors - Internacional (4 - 1)'05-09-28 Banfield - Fluminense (0 - 0)'05-09-04 Brazil - Chile (5 - 0)'05-08-23 Cerro Porteno - Guaraní (1 - 2)'05-06-22 Greece - Mexico (0 - 0)'05-06-15 Germany - Australia (4 - 3)'05-05-26 River Plate - LDU Quito (4 - 2)'05-05-18 Banfield - Ind. Medellin (3 - 0)'05-04-21 Universidad de Chile - Sao Paulo (1 - 1)'05-04-12 Bolívar - Danubio (2 - 0)'05-04-06 Boca Juniors - Pachuca (4 - 0)'05-03-30 Argentina - Colombia (1 - 0)'05-03-27 Brazil - Peru (1 - 0)'05-03-17 LDU Quito - Santos FC (2 - 1)'05-03-03 River Plate - Nacional (UR) (1 - 0)'04-10-13 Chile - Argentina (0 - 0)'04-08-24 Libertad - Cerro Porteno (0 - 2)'04-06-25 Argentina - Brazil (2 - 2)'04-06-17 Peru - Argentina (0 - 1)'04-06-09 Sao Paulo - Once Caldas (0 - 0)'04-06-07 Argentina - Ecuador (6 - 1)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)



Other Encounters
2017-08-31 Uruguay - Argentina (0 - 0) Carrillo2016-09-01 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Bascunan2015-06-16 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Ricci2013-10-15 Uruguay - Argentina (3 - 2) Lima Henrique2012-10-12 Argentina - Uruguay (3 - 0) Pedro Vuaden2011-07-16 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 1) Amarilla2008-10-11 Argentina - Uruguay (2 - 1) Torres Núñez2005-10-12 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 0) Mendonca2004-10-09 Argentina - Uruguay (4 - 2) Mendonca2004-06-13 Argentina - Uruguay (4 - 2) Selman2001-11-14 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 1) Merk2000-10-08 Argentina - Uruguay (2 - 1) Rezende Freitas1999-07-07 Argentina - Uruguay (2 - 0) Hidalgo1997-10-12 Argentina - Uruguay (0 - 0) Vinicius Cerdeira1997-01-12 Uruguay - Argentina (0 - 0) Rezende Freitas1989-07-14 Uruguay - Argentina (2 - 0) Cezar Coelho1989-07-08 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Diaz Palacio1987-07-09 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 0) Jacome Guerrero1986-06-16 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Agnolin1967-02-02 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 0) Gasc Opazo1959-12-16 Uruguay - Argentina (5 - 0) Gomes Sobrinho1959-03-30 Argentina - Uruguay (4 - 1) Ramirez Alvarez1957-03-20 Argentina - Uruguay (4 - 0) Hieger1956-02-15 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 0) Nicola1955-03-27 Argentina - Uruguay (6 - 1) Robles Robles1947-12-28 Argentina - Uruguay (3 - 1) Hayn1946-02-02 Argentina - Uruguay (3 - 1) Vianna1945-02-25 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Las Heras1942-02-07 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 0) Rojas1941-02-23 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Vargas1937-01-23 Argentina - Uruguay (2 - 3) Vargas1935-01-27 Argentina - Uruguay (0 - 3) Reginatto1930-07-30 Uruguay - Argentina (4 - 2) Langenus1929-11-17 Argentina - Uruguay (2 - 0) Barba1927-11-20 Argentina - Uruguay (3 - 2) Thurner1926-10-24 Argentina - Uruguay (0 - 2) Barba1924-11-02 Uruguay - Argentina (0 - 0) Fanta1923-12-02 Uruguay - Argentina (2 - 0) Carneiro de Campos1922-10-08 Uruguay - Argentina (0 - 1) Santos1921-10-30 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 0) Santos1920-09-12 Argentina - Uruguay (1 - 1) Jiménez1919-05-13 Argentina - Uruguay (2 - 3) Todd1917-10-14 Uruguay - Argentina (1 - 0) Livingstone1916-07-17 Argentina - Uruguay (0 - 0) Fanta

One here, one there

FIFA WC 2010 QUALIFIERS - S. AMERICA :
Uruguay - Argentina, 0 - 1. Centenario, Montevideo, Uruguay, 2009-10-14

A real final in a temple of football like Centenario stadium. Two teams that fought more than played, and a very well known referee who did what he always does: handling the game, not refereeing it. One here, one there... a yellow for the Blues, another one for the Light Blues... Amarilla never liked problems. And he referees trying to make everybody feel happy. I think he shouldn´t have become a referee.

Amarilla
It was a hard game, with hard actions and too many fouls. But it was also what we were expecting: Uruguay tend to play like this, and this Argentina of Maradona, plays very differently to how he did in his time. In the middle of this situation, Amarilla started whistling... a bit for Uruguay, another bit for Argentina. He kept the yellow score drawn, and he had to send a red to an Uruguayan because he made a very stupid foul when Argentinian Gutiérrez was about tu enter the area. Argentina´s goal came from that idiot action.

0-1
Uruguayans suspected from Amarilla. During the previous days, press said it was a "dangerous referee" and that he was going to favor Argentina. Well... the referee didn´t have a good night, but he didn´t directly influence the result. Uruguay had a good starting but then could not do the same kind of game that they did against Ecuador in Quito. After the game, Uruguayan coach Tabárez accused again Amarilla of having "whistled too much", and in "Argentina way".

Mistakes
The referee showed 8 yellows. 2 of them should have been direct reds, one each. But as I said, he didn´t want problems... For the same reason, when Heinze pushed an Uruguayan attacker inside Arg area, the referee from Paraguay just said "go on !!". An easier decision, and a more confortable ending.

Celebrations?
Argentina qualified to the World Cup, but I think there´s nothing to be proud about, except for the effort of some of the players. The national team didn´t have ideas and had to wait for the final game to celebrate the qualification. There are lots of things to check and improve. Uruguay will play an extra game against Costa Rica, and they also will have to improve if they want to get their South African trip.

Maradona
After the game, an excited Diego Maradona offered a press conference. He took revenge of previous press criticism, and said he dedicated the victory to "all the Argentinians, except for the press". To them, he dedicated a rude insult: "Suck it to me", he said. A shame.

From our reporter: Sheriff