Wilmar Roldan matches

Home - Referees - Wilmar Roldan


© 
 
Date
2014-06-13
Match
Mexico-Cameroon
 
-
Result
1 - 0
Referee decisions
Yellow
1 - 1
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
7.5
7.4
Members:
6.6
6.8
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
8.0
Control:
6.2
Calls:
9.0
Style:
9.7
Fitness:
9.7
Positioning:
8.5
General assessment
 
Reports for this match (5)
1) report by daanbeckers
7.5
Control: No problems.
5.0
Calls: Two offside calls against Mexico, one of them was completely wrong and the other was at least very questionable.
7.0
Style: Not that great.
8.5
Fitness: He was physicly very strong.
7.5
Positioning: A bit off here and there.
7.1
General assessment
Wilmar Roldan matches
'17-03-16 Peñarol - Atlético Tucumán (2 - 1)'17-02-16 Union Espanola - The Strongest (1 - 1)'17-02-09 Olimpia Asuncion - Independiente del Valle (3 - 1)'16-11-15 Peru - Brazil (0 - 2)'16-09-14 Emelec - Deportivo La Guaira (0 - 0)'16-09-06 Peru - Ecuador (2 - 1)'16-08-25 Lanús - Independiente (0 - 2)'16-08-17 Cerro Porteno - Fénix (2 - 0)'16-07-07 Independiente del Valle - Boca Juniors (2 - 1)'16-06-16 USA - Ecuador (2 - 1)'16-06-08 Ecuador - Peru (2 - 2)'16-05-11 Sao Paulo - Atlético Mineiro (1 - 0)'16-05-04 River Plate - Independiente del Valle (1 - 0)'16-04-12 Toluca - San Lorenzo (2 - 1)'16-03-29 Paraguay - Brazil (2 - 2)'16-02-25 Rosario Central - Nacional (UR) (1 - 1)'15-12-13 TP Mazembe - Sanfrecce Hiroshima (0 - 3)'15-11-17 Uruguay - Chile (3 - 0)'15-09-30 LDU Quito - River Plate (1 - 0)'15-09-17 Libertad - Universidad Católica (1 - 0)'15-07-04 Chile - Argentina (0 - 0)'15-06-25 Bolivia - Peru (1 - 3)'15-06-13 Argentina - Paraguay (2 - 2)'15-05-27 Cruzeiro - River Plate (0 - 3)'15-05-14 Racing Club - Montevideo Wanderers (2 - 1)'15-05-06 Atlético Mineiro - Internacional (2 - 2)'15-03-18 Sao Paulo - San Lorenzo (1 - 0)'15-02-18 Palestino - Boca Juniors (0 - 2)'14-11-18 Peru - Paraguay (2 - 1)'14-10-23 Deportivo Capiatá - Boca Juniors (0 - 1)'14-10-15 Goiás - Emelec (1 - 0)'14-08-06 Club Nacional - San Lorenzo (1 - 1)'14-06-22 Korea Republic - Algeria (2 - 4)• '14-06-13 Mexico - Cameroon (1 - 0)'14-05-07 Club Nacional - Arsenal de Sarandí (1 - 0)'14-03-26 Atletico Paranaense - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 3)'14-03-11 Real Garcilaso - Universidad de Chile (1 - 2)'14-01-29 Deportivo Quito - Botafogo (1 - 0)'13-11-07 Vélez Sarsfield - Ponte Preta (0 - 2)'13-08-14 Ecuador - Spain (0 - 2)'13-07-24 Atlético Mineiro - Olimpia Asuncion (2 - 0)'13-06-27 Portugal u20 - Cuba u20 (5 - 0)'13-06-21 France u20 - Ghana u20 (3 - 1)'13-06-02 Brazil - England (2 - 2)'13-05-02 Emelec - Fluminense (2 - 1)'13-04-18 Libertad - Tigres (3 - 5)'13-03-22 Uruguay - Paraguay (1 - 1)'13-03-12 Universidad de Chile - Newell's Old Boys (0 - 2)'13-03-07 Sao Paulo - Arsenal de Sarandí (1 - 1)'13-02-19 Toluca - Nacional (UR) (2 - 3)'13-02-12 Emelec - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 0)'13-01-30 Bolívar - Sao Paulo (4 - 3)'13-01-23 LDU Quito - Gremio (1 - 0)'12-09-11 Peru - Argentina (1 - 1)'12-08-04 Great Britain OT - Korea Republic OT (1 - 1)'12-07-26 Gabon OT - Switzerland OT (1 - 1)'12-07-04 Corinthians - Boca Juniors (2 - 0)'12-06-14 Boca Juniors - Universidad de Chile (2 - 0)'12-05-24 Universidad de Chile - Libertad (1 - 1)'12-05-09 Union Espanola - Boca Juniors (2 - 3)'12-04-17 Deportivo Quito - Guadalajara (5 - 0)'12-04-12 Flamengo - Lanús (3 - 0)'12-03-21 Vasco da Gama - Libertad (2 - 0)'12-03-13 Alianza Lima - Nacional (UR) (1 - 0)'12-02-15 Deportivo Tachira - Corinthians (1 - 1)'12-02-09 Emelec - Olimpia Asuncion (1 - 0)'11-12-11 Millonarios - Junior Barranquilla (3 - 0)'11-11-17 Universidad de Chile - Arsenal de Sarandí (3 - 0)'11-10-26 Libertad - Sao Paulo (2 - 0)'11-10-20 Universitario - Godoy Cruz (1 - 1)'11-10-07 Argentina - Chile (4 - 1)'11-09-22 Deportivo Cali - Santa Fe (1 - 1)'11-09-06 Ecuador - Costa Rica (4 - 0)'11-08-10 Independiente - Internacional (2 - 1)'11-07-23 Peru - Venezuela (4 - 1)'11-07-09 Brazil - Paraguay (2 - 2)'11-07-04 Uruguay - Peru (1 - 1)'11-06-01 Cerro Porteno - Santos FC (3 - 3)'11-05-05 LDU Quito - Vélez Sarsfield (0 - 2)'11-04-20 Argentinos Juniors - Fluminense (2 - 4)'11-04-06 Jaguaras Chiapas - Internacional (1 - 0)'11-03-17 LDU Quito - Peñarol (5 - 0)'11-03-02 América - Fluminense (1 - 0)'11-02-12 Chile u20 - Ecuador u20 (0 - 1)'11-02-06 Argentina u20 - Brazil u20 (2 - 1)'11-01-24 Peru u20 - Venezuela u20 (1 - 1)'11-01-16 Argentina u20 - Uruguay u20 (2 - 1)'10-10-19 LDU Quito - Union San Felipe (6 - 1)'10-08-19 Montenegro u15 - Singapore u15 (2 - 3)'10-05-23 Qatar u20 - Russia u20 (2 - 2)'10-05-19 Denmark u20 - Russia u20 (3 - 1)'10-05-06 Internacional - Banfield (2 - 0)'10-03-31 Cruzeiro - Vélez Sarsfield (3 - 0)'10-03-26 Paraguay u20 - Chile u20 (2 - 5)'10-03-10 Caracas FC - Flamengo (1 - 3)'10-02-17 Deportivo Cuenca - Banfield (1 - 4)'09-10-21 River Plate (Uruguay) - San Lorenzo (0 - 1)'09-09-24 LDU Quito - Lanús (4 - 0)'09-08-26 Atlético Mineiro - Goiás (1 - 1)'09-04-01 Ecuador - Paraguay (1 - 1)'09-02-25 Caracas FC - Lanús (3 - 1)'09-02-17 LDU Quito - Palmeiras (3 - 2)'09-01-31 Argentina u20 - Paraguay u20 (1 - 1)'09-01-26 Chile u20 - Brazil u20 (0 - 2)'09-01-22 Uruguay u20 - Chile u20 (3 - 2)'08-08-05 Deportivo Quito - Universitario (2 - 1)'08-05-14 Boca Juniors - Atlas (2 - 2)'08-04-16 San Lorenzo - Caracas FC (3 - 0)'08-03-25 Maracaibo - Atlas (1 - 1)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)

Great expectations...

FIFA WC 2014 group stage:
Mexico - Cameroon, 1 - 0. Arena das Dunas, Natal, Brazil, 2014-06-13

As gefluegel has remarked - the hype about Roldan, being the novice brilliant kid of South Amrica's refereeing, alerted all European football watchers to the opportunity to see Mr. Roldan in action. Sorry, but he was not the one (especially due to Mr. Clavijo's horrendous performance) to rescue WC 2014 refereeing from derision.

The match
Cameroon was never up to it. Mexico dominated, even domineered events on the pitch. They played more then decent football, exposing Cameroon's vulnerability in defence and mid-field, and the final scoreline is not doing service to the real quality-gap between these two teams. It could have been much worse for Cameroon, hadn't they been hugely assisted and thus rescued, by ar1, and to a certain degree - by the ref. himself.

Ars or a nightmare at noon
Mr. Clavijo, ar1, who had been assisting Oscar Ruiz in WC 2010, had a horrible day. It started from kick-off and got worse durinthe first half. Fortunately for him, the contest was so one-sided, he had not much to do wrong during the second half. It all started in the second minute: Assou-Ekotto pushed a Mexican player close to Mr. Clavijo, but astonishingly, the ar awarded Cameroon with a free-kick. two minutes later, a Mexican attempt to cross the ball inti Cameroon's penalty-area, was deflected by Assou-Ekotto, but the ar, perfectky positioned and clear sighted, awarded a goal-kick instead of a corner-kick. Then Clavibo ruked dos Santos offside (11'), disallowing the goal he scored. I think the ar should be given the benefit of the doubt: although the replay suggests the player was parallel to the last defenders but the goalie, it a terribly close call, and in cases like these the ar might get away with his decision, whatever it has been. But this was not the end of it. The huge mistake waited "around the corner (kick)". In the 29th minute Mexico delivered a corner-kick from their left-hand side. The ball was headed in the Cameroon penalty-area, thus lengthening the cross and reaching dos Santos on the right, close to the edge of the goal-area. He scored just to realise he was adjudged offside and the goal was disallowed. The main problem with that decision - the cross-distance was lengthened by a Cameroonian header (which should have been detected by Mr. Roldan!). Secondly, even had there been a Mexican header, a Cameroonian player played dos Santon on-side as he, as well as his goalie, were closer to Cameroon's goal-line than the Mexican forward. Clavijo was so perplexed from then on, thus not flagging for a Mexican offside when there was an obvious one (40'). Mr. Diaz demonstrated a wholly different offside approach. When he was the one to decide Mexican offside/onside positions, he rarely decided the former. Thus one remained puzzled about the instances where no flag was raised in the second half, while no replay was provided to have a better and more comprehensive view (60',63', 73', 81').

Ref
Mr. Roldan is in great shape, close to the action, but well-positioned to get into players' way. he made some mistakes of his own, and in other cases was party to his ars' mistakes, concerning throw-ins (direction and application of the two-hands rule) and corners/goal-kicks (e.g. 4', 6', 18', 22', 25', 45'). There some mistakes in foul detection or direction (e.g. 4', 10', 26', 48', 52', 76'). I would mention two cases in particular. In the 54th minute, Peralta (later, to score the Mexican goal, 61') came much closer than 9.15 metreswhen a Cameroonian free-kick was taken without any reaction from the ref. In the 52nd minute, M'Bia hit an opponent blatantly in his face while running for the ball. Unfortunately for the ref., who was the closest on earth to the incident, he was positioned behind the Mexican's back. "feeling" there was a foul, the ref. penalised Cameroon, but not seeing exactly how the foul was committed - prevented him from duly cautioning the culprit. Finally, and certainly worst of all - Mr. Roldan of all people, should have seen (29') that the ball reached dos Santos due to a Cameroonian header, and hence - oerruled his hapless ar and allowed the goal to stay. Saying all that, Mr. Roldan had a second half much calmer and more balanced second half, which enabled him to demonstrate some of his positives he had been renowned for (coolish attitudee. clever use of the advantage rule)

From our reporter: adir