Wilmar Roldan matches

Home - Referees - Wilmar Roldan


© 
 
Date
2012-07-26
Match
Gabon OT-Switzerland OT
 
-
Result
1 - 1
Referee decisions
Yellow
2 - 2
Red
0 - 1
Penalty
0 - 1
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
7.3
7.4
Members:
6
6.8
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
9.0
Control: No question, he had full control.
6.0
Calls: Some good calls, but he missed some bad fouls.
9.0
Neutrality:
6.0
Style: He's clearly a strong referee, but he could be more relaxed some times. More communication with this young players of other continents needed.
7.5
General assessment
 
Reports for this match (1)
1) report by Luigi
6.0
Control: Way too many careless fouls went without as much as a warning
6.0
Calls: The only salvation is that he did get the simulation and did deal with it.
9.0
Neutrality:
7.0
Style: He was calm, mostly in good position and decent fitness
7.0
General assessment
This is the first time I have seen Roldan work and was not impressed. Maybe this is his way to take risk and allow the game to flow, but he must deal with reckless challenges and he did not. 49th min play on, on a nasty foul with a man on the pitch and no real advantage; he should have just given the yellow which was bordering on pink. Like to see him again.
Wilmar Roldan matches
'17-10-31 Lanús - River Plate (4 - 2)'17-09-13 San Lorenzo - Lanús (2 - 0)'17-09-05 Bolivia - Chile (1 - 0)'17-08-10 Botafogo - Nacional (UR) (2 - 0)'17-07-13 Nacional Potosí - Estudiantes (0 - 1)'17-06-25 Germany - Cameroon (3 - 1)'17-06-17 Russia - New Zealand (2 - 0)'17-05-24 Palmeiras - Atlético Tucumán (3 - 1)'17-05-03 Atletico Paranaense - San Lorenzo (0 - 3)'17-04-27 Zulia - Lanús (1 - 1)'17-04-20 Guaraní - Gremio (1 - 1)'17-03-28 Bolivia - Argentina (2 - 0)'17-03-16 Peñarol - Atlético Tucumán (2 - 1)'17-02-16 Union Espanola - The Strongest (1 - 1)'17-02-09 Olimpia Asuncion - Independiente del Valle (3 - 1)'16-11-15 Peru - Brazil (0 - 2)'16-09-14 Emelec - Deportivo La Guaira (0 - 0)'16-09-06 Peru - Ecuador (2 - 1)'16-08-25 Lanús - Independiente (0 - 2)'16-08-17 Cerro Porteno - Fénix (2 - 0)'16-07-07 Independiente del Valle - Boca Juniors (2 - 1)'16-06-16 USA - Ecuador (2 - 1)'16-06-08 Ecuador - Peru (2 - 2)'16-05-11 Sao Paulo - Atlético Mineiro (1 - 0)'16-05-04 River Plate - Independiente del Valle (1 - 0)'16-04-12 Toluca - San Lorenzo (2 - 1)'16-03-29 Paraguay - Brazil (2 - 2)'16-02-25 Rosario Central - Nacional (UR) (1 - 1)'15-12-13 TP Mazembe - Sanfrecce Hiroshima (0 - 3)'15-11-17 Uruguay - Chile (3 - 0)'15-09-30 LDU Quito - River Plate (1 - 0)'15-09-17 Libertad - Universidad Católica (1 - 0)'15-07-04 Chile - Argentina (0 - 0)'15-06-25 Bolivia - Peru (1 - 3)'15-06-13 Argentina - Paraguay (2 - 2)'15-05-27 Cruzeiro - River Plate (0 - 3)'15-05-14 Racing Club - Montevideo Wanderers (2 - 1)'15-05-06 Atlético Mineiro - Internacional (2 - 2)'15-03-18 Sao Paulo - San Lorenzo (1 - 0)'15-02-18 Palestino - Boca Juniors (0 - 2)'14-11-18 Peru - Paraguay (2 - 1)'14-10-23 Deportivo Capiatá - Boca Juniors (0 - 1)'14-10-15 Goiás - Emelec (1 - 0)'14-08-06 Club Nacional - San Lorenzo (1 - 1)'14-06-22 Korea Republic - Algeria (2 - 4)'14-06-13 Mexico - Cameroon (1 - 0)'14-05-07 Club Nacional - Arsenal de Sarandí (1 - 0)'14-03-26 Atletico Paranaense - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 3)'14-03-11 Real Garcilaso - Universidad de Chile (1 - 2)'14-01-29 Deportivo Quito - Botafogo (1 - 0)'13-11-07 Vélez Sarsfield - Ponte Preta (0 - 2)'13-08-14 Ecuador - Spain (0 - 2)'13-07-24 Atlético Mineiro - Olimpia Asuncion (2 - 0)'13-06-27 Portugal u20 - Cuba u20 (5 - 0)'13-06-21 France u20 - Ghana u20 (3 - 1)'13-06-02 Brazil - England (2 - 2)'13-05-02 Emelec - Fluminense (2 - 1)'13-04-18 Libertad - Tigres (3 - 5)'13-03-22 Uruguay - Paraguay (1 - 1)'13-03-12 Universidad de Chile - Newell's Old Boys (0 - 2)'13-03-07 Sao Paulo - Arsenal de Sarandí (1 - 1)'13-02-19 Toluca - Nacional (UR) (2 - 3)'13-02-12 Emelec - Vélez Sarsfield (1 - 0)'13-01-30 Bolívar - Sao Paulo (4 - 3)'13-01-23 LDU Quito - Gremio (1 - 0)'12-09-11 Peru - Argentina (1 - 1)'12-08-04 Great Britain OT - Korea Republic OT (1 - 1)• '12-07-26 Gabon OT - Switzerland OT (1 - 1)'12-07-04 Corinthians - Boca Juniors (2 - 0)'12-06-14 Boca Juniors - Universidad de Chile (2 - 0)'12-05-24 Universidad de Chile - Libertad (1 - 1)'12-05-09 Union Espanola - Boca Juniors (2 - 3)'12-04-17 Deportivo Quito - Guadalajara (5 - 0)'12-04-12 Flamengo - Lanús (3 - 0)'12-03-21 Vasco da Gama - Libertad (2 - 0)'12-03-13 Alianza Lima - Nacional (UR) (1 - 0)'12-02-15 Deportivo Tachira - Corinthians (1 - 1)'12-02-09 Emelec - Olimpia Asuncion (1 - 0)'11-12-11 Millonarios - Junior Barranquilla (3 - 0)'11-11-17 Universidad de Chile - Arsenal de Sarandí (3 - 0)'11-10-26 Libertad - Sao Paulo (2 - 0)'11-10-20 Universitario - Godoy Cruz (1 - 1)'11-10-07 Argentina - Chile (4 - 1)'11-09-22 Deportivo Cali - Santa Fe (1 - 1)'11-09-06 Ecuador - Costa Rica (4 - 0)'11-08-10 Independiente - Internacional (2 - 1)'11-07-23 Peru - Venezuela (4 - 1)'11-07-09 Brazil - Paraguay (2 - 2)'11-07-04 Uruguay - Peru (1 - 1)'11-06-01 Cerro Porteno - Santos FC (3 - 3)'11-05-05 LDU Quito - Vélez Sarsfield (0 - 2)'11-04-20 Argentinos Juniors - Fluminense (2 - 4)'11-04-06 Jaguaras Chiapas - Internacional (1 - 0)'11-03-17 LDU Quito - Peñarol (5 - 0)'11-03-02 América - Fluminense (1 - 0)'11-02-12 Chile u20 - Ecuador u20 (0 - 1)'11-02-06 Argentina u20 - Brazil u20 (2 - 1)'11-01-24 Peru u20 - Venezuela u20 (1 - 1)'11-01-16 Argentina u20 - Uruguay u20 (2 - 1)'10-10-19 LDU Quito - Union San Felipe (6 - 1)'10-08-19 Montenegro u15 - Singapore u15 (2 - 3)'10-05-23 Qatar u20 - Russia u20 (2 - 2)'10-05-19 Denmark u20 - Russia u20 (3 - 1)'10-05-06 Internacional - Banfield (2 - 0)'10-03-31 Cruzeiro - Vélez Sarsfield (3 - 0)'10-03-26 Paraguay u20 - Chile u20 (2 - 5)'10-03-10 Caracas FC - Flamengo (1 - 3)'10-02-17 Deportivo Cuenca - Banfield (1 - 4)'09-10-21 River Plate (Uruguay) - San Lorenzo (0 - 1)'09-09-24 LDU Quito - Lanús (4 - 0)'09-08-26 Atlético Mineiro - Goiás (1 - 1)'09-04-01 Ecuador - Paraguay (1 - 1)'09-02-25 Caracas FC - Lanús (3 - 1)'09-02-17 LDU Quito - Palmeiras (3 - 2)'09-01-31 Argentina u20 - Paraguay u20 (1 - 1)'09-01-26 Chile u20 - Brazil u20 (0 - 2)'09-01-22 Uruguay u20 - Chile u20 (3 - 2)'08-08-05 Deportivo Quito - Universitario (2 - 1)'08-05-14 Boca Juniors - Atlas (2 - 2)'08-04-16 San Lorenzo - Caracas FC (3 - 0)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)

Good, but...

FIFA OLYMPIC GAMES 2012 group stage:
Gabon OT - Switzerland OT, 1 - 1. St James' Park, Newcastle, England, 2012-07-26

It was the first time I saw Wilmar Roldan, Colombias Nr. 1 . He took some good decisions but there were things to improve.

Early penalty...
I was curious to see Roldan because this young referee has made it to the top of South America referees in a short time. He has already some important games in his palmares. Of course, he is used to take important decisions and in this match he didn't hesitate to give a penalty after a few minutes. I watched the replays a couple of times, and I tend to say that he was mistaken to give the penalty because the Gabon player simply hit over the ball. But there was no foul in my opinion. He gave no yellow card for this "foul" an he was right. And there was a good decision that the penalty had to be retaken because the players went in to the box too early. Later he missed some yellow cards for nasty fouls so his card policy wasn't consistent enough. The yellow-red to a Swiss player for diving was a great call.

Future
I think he should get a second match. I hope he can adapt his south american style (strict, severe) a little bit. In games with european and african teams you have to comunicate more with players. In this match, Roldan seemed a little bit distant altough he had full control during the whole match. But as I always say: It's a difference how to handle a match in your home country compared to international tournament with teams of other continents. A referee not only has to take decisions on the pitch. He also has to lead a match with his own personality. This is the point which this young and promising referee can surely improve. If so, he will led important matches even at international tournaments.

From our reporter: Mooazrt21