Carlos Velasco Carballo matches

Home - Referees - Carlos Velasco Carballo


© as.com
 
Date
2011-05-18
Match
Porto-Braga
 
-
Result
1 - 0
Referee decisions
Yellow
3 - 5
Red
0 - 0
Penalty
0 - 0
Referee assessment
 
this match
overall
Reporters:
5.7
7
Members:
7.4
6.9
 
Matches Bio Did you know? Palmares
7.0
Control: Sometimes was hard but he did the best he could. Some errors take some respect and credibility that the players had for him in the start.
6.0
Calls: already talked about the errors. assistants were good in off-side situations.
7.0
Neutrality: a bit pro-Porto. But harmed both teams.
7.0
Style: calm but can be severe. always good position.
6.8
General assessment
 
Reports for this match (14)
1) report by lorenzosavini
8.0
Control:
8.0
Calls:
9.0
Neutrality:
7.0
Style:
8.0
General assessment
Carlos Velasco Carballo matches
'16-06-25 Croatia - Portugal (0 - 1)'16-06-20 Slovakia - England (0 - 0)'16-06-11 Albania - Switzerland (0 - 1)'16-04-12 Manchester City - PSG (1 - 0)'16-04-07 Dortmund - Liverpool (1 - 1)'16-03-10 Liverpool - Manchester United (2 - 0)'16-02-16 PSG - Chelsea F.C. (2 - 1)'15-11-24 Porto - Dynamo Kyiv (0 - 2)'15-11-15 Hungary - Norway (2 - 1)'15-10-21 CSKA Moskva - Manchester United (1 - 1)'15-10-08 Ireland - Germany (1 - 0)'15-09-16 Olympiakos - Bayern Munich (0 - 3)'15-09-08 Sweden - Austria (1 - 4)'15-08-26 Leverkusen - Lazio (3 - 0)'15-06-13 Northern Ireland - Romania (0 - 0)'15-04-15 Porto - Bayern Munich (3 - 1)'15-03-28 Croatia - Norway (5 - 1)'15-03-12 Everton - Dynamo Kyiv (2 - 1)'15-02-19 Tottenham Hotspur - Fiorentina (1 - 1)'14-12-10 Ajax - APOEL (4 - 0)'14-10-22 Anderlecht - Arsenal (1 - 2)'14-10-13 Iceland - Netherlands (2 - 0)'14-09-30 Schalke 04 - Maribor (1 - 1)'14-08-19 Kobenhavn - Leverkusen (2 - 3)'14-07-04 Brazil - Colombia (2 - 1)'14-06-25 Bosnia-Herzegovina - Iran (3 - 1)'14-06-19 Uruguay - England (2 - 1)'14-04-01 Manchester United - Bayern Munich (1 - 1)'14-02-26 Galatasaray - Chelsea F.C. (1 - 1)'13-12-18 Raja Casablanca - Atlético Mineiro (3 - 1)'13-11-26 Dortmund - Napoli (3 - 1)'13-11-05 Manchester City - CSKA Moskva (5 - 2)'13-10-11 Slovenia - Norway (3 - 0)'13-10-01 Steaua - Chelsea F.C. (0 - 4)'13-09-06 Italy - Bulgaria (1 - 0)'13-08-27 Arsenal - Fenerbahce SK (2 - 0)'13-04-10 Juventus - Bayern Munich (0 - 2)'13-02-14 Zenit - Liverpool (2 - 0)'13-02-06 Romania - Australia (3 - 2)'12-11-20 Galatasaray - Manchester United (1 - 0)'12-11-07 Chelsea F.C. - Shakhtar (3 - 2)'12-09-18 Montpellier - Arsenal (1 - 2)'12-09-07 Netherlands - Turkey (2 - 0)'12-08-29 Celtic - Helsingborg (2 - 0)'12-06-17 Denmark - Germany (1 - 2)'12-06-08 Poland - Greece (1 - 1)'12-05-22 Qatar - Albania (1 - 2)'12-03-28 Marseille - Bayern Munich (0 - 2)'12-03-08 Sporting - Manchester City (1 - 0)'12-02-21 Napoli - Chelsea F.C. (3 - 1)'11-12-06 Porto - Zenit (0 - 0)'11-11-11 Ukraine - Germany (3 - 3)'11-11-02 Benfica - Basel (1 - 1)'11-09-28 Arsenal - Olympiakos (2 - 1)'11-09-06 Croatia - Israel (3 - 1)'11-08-24 Plzen - Kobenhavn (2 - 1)• '11-05-18 Porto - Braga (1 - 0)'11-04-26 Schalke 04 - Manchester United (0 - 2)'11-03-25 Hungary - Netherlands (0 - 4)'11-03-15 Manchester United - Marseille (2 - 1)'10-12-07 Twente - Tottenham Hotspur (3 - 3)'10-11-17 Sweden - Germany (0 - 0)'10-10-19 Spartak Moskva - Chelsea F.C. (0 - 2)'10-09-15 Shakhtar - Partizan (1 - 0)'10-09-03 Estonia - Italy (1 - 2)'10-08-26 Utrecht - Celtic (4 - 0)'10-08-11 Norway - France (2 - 1)'10-08-04 PAOK - Ajax (3 - 3)'10-02-18 Kobenhavn - Marseille (1 - 3)'09-12-17 Dinamo Zagreb - Timisoara (1 - 2)'09-11-05 Hamburger SV - Celtic (0 - 0)'09-09-17 Basel - AS Roma (2 - 0)'09-08-27 Aston Villa - Rapid Wien (2 - 1)'09-07-30 Brøndby - Legia Warszawa (1 - 1)'09-07-21 Sheriff - Inter Turku (1 - 0)'09-06-06 Cyprus - Montenegro (2 - 2)'08-10-25 San Marino u19 - Azerbaijan u19 (0 - 5)'08-09-09 Romania u21 - Wales u21 (0 - 3)'08-07-30 Anorthosis - Rapid Wien (3 - 0)'08-05-31 France u19 - Italy u19 (0 - 2)'08-05-26 Italy u19 - Sweden u19 (2 - 0)'08-03-26 Israel - Chile (1 - 0)
(A click on 'All matches' will show all international matches for this ref that we at WorldReferee know about - including those we didn't report on.)

Dublin's dream ends in disappointment.

UEFA EUROPA LEAGUE 2010 - 2011 final:
Porto - Braga, 1 - 0. Dublin Arena, Dublin, Ireland, 2011-05-18

It was a dream for Carballo this final, but in the end I believe he is not very happy with the decisions he made. Two Portuguese teams, both knowing each other inside out, were waiting most of the game and by consequence never showed what Portuguese football has to offer. In the end the right one won.

The game
This game is one of those finals you hope to finish fast. Both teams waiting, no big opportunities to see, a lot of fouls...but everyone will say ...it's normal for a final...can be normal but is bad for the show.

Carballo's nomination
I was against his nomination. For 2 reasons: a) I don't like the referees that in 1 or 2 seasons reach the Elite and go to a final very quickly. Is bad for the referee and can be bad for the match; b) Two teams with a Latin way of playing so the correct referee would be someone with a British style (UEFA did this in the semis ...why they went in an adventure know?...a bit political this nomination).
But of course I recognize quality and charisma in Carballo, he is a referee capable of finals, but not all finals.

Carballo's negative aspects
21' missed a foul for Braga in frontal position near the box. Was a foul and debatable YC. He just said play-on. The guy who was fouled was Viana and things were already a bit tense between the ref and that player.
30' Missed a red card for Silvio. In a nasty and reckless foul from behind and with possibility of injury he just showed the YC. Ok it was in the middle of the match but he had enough reasons to pull out the red.
55' In a moment Hulk was going to the goal Carballo stopped the match to score a previous foul to Porto, when Porto had the possession and a goal scoring opportunity.
72' Missed the second YC to Sapunaru. If he has criteria for one situation it's reasonable he uses that same criteria in the others. Here he chose to be blind.

And the positive stuff
I liked the style and the positioning, he is well adapted to this 6 ref teams way. Apart from that he was regular, just some mistakes happening. Also tried to stop the game as litlle as he could, especially in the final 10 minutes he was very good.

to finish
My title says it all. The best team in the EL was the winner and no doubt about the value and quality. The referee is one of the revelations of this season. I had expectations for this final but the 3 teams disappointed me.

From our reporter: fctav